Eff_Ehl

my p4p list is based on fighters actual skills and whether they would win hypothetical fights rather than their resumes... and i have Pacquiao 2nd.

Khan will knock him out in a few rounds cos the guy is a midget i cant wait for Khan to fight someone decent and hopefully be humbled

i think Calzaghe should beat Hopkins convincingly if he fights his best but i'm worried Hopkins is being underestimated.. i reckon he still has it in him to make this a difficult fight

Duran, Hagler, Hearns, Ray Leonard... i just love that period

i think this'll be alot closer than people think, but i still say Haye will win

1.Mikkel Kessler 2.Jeff Lacy 3.Chris Eubank 4.Robin Reid 5.Charles Brewer

maybe the $20m was referring to insurance offered in case he gets injured or something?

i'd say Mayweather.. but my knowledge of pre-'80s boxing is limited to say the least

Hagler Monzon Robinson LaMotta Hopkins

1. Floyd Mayweather 2. Joe Calzaghe 3. Manny Pacquiao 4. Juan Manuel Marquez 5. Isreal Vasquez 6. Juan Diaz 7. Miguel Cotto 8. Rafeal Marquez 9. Winky Wright 10. Bernard Hopkins

both.......

he already is an atg, but beating all these guys would really push him up higher on the list! co-sign . . .

Kessler, the way he seemed in the interviews before and after the Calzaghe fight won me over as a fan

although the author comes accross as very biased, i pretty much agree with the results and factors that would contribute to each fight

don't know about this year, but i think besides Mayweather and Calzaghe most of them will soon enough.. all look beatable to me

Calzaghe with Mayweather a close second

He will be one of the best but he definitely won't be the p4p king at any point and I expect him to suffer a few defeats during his career. I can actually see his career panning out a bit like Hatton's. nah he's way more talented than Hatton and a lot less likable.. i doubt he'll ever be p4p king.. but should be top 10 one day aslong as he doesnt get exposed once he steps up a class in opponents

i'd guess Cotto even though he'd be alot weaker at 140

Hopkins vs. Eubank Hopkins vs. Toney Hopkins vs. Benn Hopkins vs. McClellan Hopkins vs. Collins Hopkins vs. Calzaghe Hopkins vs. Jones

Joe Calzaghe is a lot better than Ricky Hatton and Hopkins is as old as moses and never remotely as good as PBF. I don't see any kind of comparisons. basically... the only comparison is that theyre both British going over to USA to fight high profile American fighters

Calzaghe is already an all-time British great so he will always have a legacy over here. I can't really comment on America 'cos i dont know how he's viewed there but if he does lose then it really shouldnt be held against him too much, although it will definitaly be a blemish on his record

Calzaghe UD... but Hopkins makes it very difficult and maybe even gets Calzaghe in trouble at some point in the fight

clearly Jeff Lacy, but i also think Jones Jr was slightly overrated.. great.. but overrated

i wouldn't mind this happening if Floyd took more than 1 fight a year, but seeing as he doesn't really do that anymore i'd rather he fought someone better

i think he beats pretty much everyone at HW except Wlad

slick technicians like Mayweather

i dunno. i rate my p4p list by who i think would win an imaginary fight if they were the same size, and i think Mayweather would beat them both

i'm neutral and i think floyd would destroy cotto

if Jones beat Calzaghe then the top 10 p4p list should be reshuffled a little and some of the underrated smaller fighters should get more recognition (aswell as give Jones the props he would deserve)

no, your mother is the biggest slapper