You guys seems to forget canelo was 19-20 when he was was at the lower weights freaking faced and older mosley at onl 20 he was a damn baby. Think about that when canelo was facing grown men the likes of mosley bivol was still facing 3 rd amateur teens.
Canelo is very hard to put down now because of his iron chin and crazy upper body head movement.
No Im thinking about Floyd, Khan, Lara, Cotto, and Liam Smith. He has not grown enough since those fights for it to make sense that top light heavyweights with power comparable to Gvozdyk to have so little visible displacement when they land punches on him. It was already perplexing vs GGG at 160, and now it's even more so vs Kovalev and Bivol at 175. People can tell stories about how GGG knocks out heavyweights in sparring, and he hits as hard as Kovalev, Beterbiev, Stevenson, etc, but we see that when he fights middleweights, even in his prime, they sometimes last late in the fight, and take many hard punches before getting stopped. They get beat up and weakened to the point they aren't threats much earlier, but they don't get taken out. Danny Jacobs still had to make 160, although he rehydrated higher (which is not the same as being a top 168 let alone a top 175 pounder), and he went 12 with GGG. So did Dereyvanchenko. Even a welterweight Kell Brook did not get KO'd. When has GGG ever KO'd someone like Trent Broadhurst at 175 with one punch? So you would expect Bivol at 175 to hit significantly harder than GGG, or at least sharper which translates to bigger snap of the head and harder just by different means. If GGG bulked up to 175, he might have a stronger upper body than Bivol, and more power in that sense, but in terms of actual punches, Bivol's stronger legs and calves especially (like Pacquiao), his longer reach and greater weight transfer, and his faster hands mean that when he lands a clean straight right on Canelo, it should have significantly bigger impact than GGG at 160.
I mean, it's been so inconsistent that it's actually hard to really think about or even articulate, but the one thing that has been consistent is that there has been a clearly different level of height, size, power, range, reach, and weight transfer at 175 compared to 160 during this era. Stevenson-Fonfara, Gvozdyk-Stevenson, all of Beterbiev's fights, Bivol's fights on HBO, it's been a different animal than 160. To use an NBA analogy, the fights at 175 have been like the small forwards in the NBA. These fights are Khawi Leonard vs Lebron or something. Whereas at 160, well there is no good analogy, but it's basically been the same thing except shorter, less muscular, less reach, and less power. Here watch the full highlights and tell me if this looks like the same division: https://youtu.be/v7D1sq1jVCg?t=85.
Or how about asking it this way, it's much easier. Canelo could not even stop a drained Chavez Jr at 164.5 pounds. Meanwhile a fully healthy Chavez Jr at 175 got stopped by a B level light heavyweight in Fonfara who does not hit any harder than Bivol does. So how come 10 pounds above where Canelo fought Chavez Jr, Bivol's punches look weaker than Fonfara's, when they should look much heavier considering it's 10 pounds even higher.
Here, Stevenson even rides away from Fonfara's semi weak left hook, the same way Canelo rides away, but it still had a big impact. Whereas when this happens with Canelo, we hear barely any sound from the microphone at the ring, and the punch just slides off and seems to make zero impact. https://youtu.be/v7D1sq1jVCg?t=116.
And again, Fonfara's punches are having big, thudding impact on another extremely strong light heavyweight. So it's already bigger and we haven't even factored in for Canelo being smaller and less strong. if there is already bigger impact now, it should be even bigger vs Canelo, who is much smaller and less strong. But we keep seeing the opposite. We don't even get this level of impact when Canelo gets hit clean at 175, let alone even more like you would expect! It makes no sense!
Here is Bivol vs Barrera. Look how big and strong Barrera is compared to Canelo, Then a few seconds later, look what Bivol's straight right hand does https://youtu.be/8RMLOFQCEsw?t=152. We didn't see that kind of impact on Canelo who is much smaller and less strong, let alone an even bigger impact like we should have seen.
Looking back over the highlights, I can grant that in some fights, Bivol does not look as powerful as Gvozdyk, making the Gvozdyk-Stevenson aspect of the comparison false, but in other fights, Bivol does (like Broadhurst and Barrera at times). In any case, he hits hard enough that when he hit Canelo, it shouldn't have looked so similar to when Liam Smith and Amir Khan hit Canelo three weight classes lower........