Great article by John McCormick from the site that talks boxing
May 07, 2012
MAYWEATHER-COTTO: THE GOOD, THE BAD, AND THE UGLY
By John McCormick
Saturday night’s mega-fight*in which*Floyd*Mayweather*defeated Miguel Cotto by a clear but competitive unanimous decision displayed everything*a big boxing event should. Skill, determination, perseverance, will power, drama, suspense, surprise, and violence were all present*throughout the twelve rounds. Many unanswered questions were answered throughout* and many were left unanswered. Let’s examine the good, the bad, and the ugly of Mayweather-Cotto.
THE GOOD
First off, I must*confess*my prediction for this fight*was completely wrong. I predicted that*Mayweather would blow*Cotto out of the water.
I was completely wrong and I am very happy to admit it. The bout was one of Mayweather’s most exciting, fan-friendly fights throughout his forty-three performances as a professional fighter. Cotto came into the ring with a plan and at times utilized it beautifully. On the other hand, fight fans had a chance to see Mayweather in a dog-fight where he had to dig down deep, persevere, and step it up a notch in order to pull out a clear victory. Both Mayweather and Cotto should be extremely proud of themselves for giving boxing fans their money’s worth throughout the entire fight.
THE BAD
Although Mayweather’s performance was amazing and one of the best of his career, he showed technical inadequacies that he has never shown before. Mild fatigue, the inability to adapt to certain things*Cotto was doing, and most importantly, his vulnerability were all on display Saturday night. Throughout the fight, Mayweather*spent too much time laying on the ropes, looking for a rest. It was*clear*he was uncomfortable with the pace that the fight was being fought at. Mayweather was getting snubbed by the left jab of Cotto, and an occasional right hand, both punches that Mayweather would’ve most likely avoided had the fight taken place a few years ago. Whether it is Mayweather’s age, the move up to the 154-pound division, the ten ounce gloves, or just simply Cotto’s game-plan is still up for debate.
One thing that is clear is that Mayweather was very uncomfortable and even embarrassed during certain moments on Saturday night, to the point where I am ready to declare that Mayweather is slowly declining in front of the boxing world’s eyes. During the twelfth and final round, Mayweather stepped on the gas pedal and had Cotto hurt. But he didn’t even attempt to follow up. Instead, he decided to coast and put his non-killer instincts on display once again.
Cotto showed tremendous skill and heart throughout the bout. All experts knew*his jab would be the key to giving Mayweather problems heading into the fight, and Cotto used it wisely. The film of Mayweather’s first fight with Jose Luis Castillo must’ve been studied thoroughly in Cotto’s camp because Cotto implemented some of the same tactics that Castillo used back in 2002, when many thought Castillio deserved to win the close decision that went in Mayweather's favor. At times, Cotto pushed Mayweather to the ropes and not let him leave. Cotto would lay on him, and jab effectively and then follow up with flurries. Some of these flurries landed and some of them didn’t, but they were fan and judge friendly punches. However, after the eighth round, Cotto seemed to gas out, like he has many times throughout his career. The Puerto Rican star was unable to make another run once round nine started and simply stopped doing the things that were bringing him success in the earlier rounds.
THE UGLY
After the bout, Mayweather*solidified his reputation as a walking contradiction. During his post-fight interview with HBO’s Larry Merchant, Mayweather made nice to his Merhcant, a former target of his ire, but claimed that promoter*Bob Arum is blocking*a fight with Manny Pacquiao from occurring. He then went on to*repeat his familiar line that if Pacquiao is the best, he should take the test. The Olympic Style Drug Testing that Mayweather has demanded throughout the three-year cycle of failed negotiations with Pacquiao is no longer an issue, as Pacquiao has said many times*he would subject himself to any type of testing that Mayweather wants. The last time Mayweather and Pacquiao attempted to make this fight happen, the negotiations failed due to Pacquiao demanding a 50/50 split in revenue and Mayweather subsequently*insisting on the lion;s share of revenues. The drug testing is no longer an issue, yet Mayweather continues to bastardize and run this moot subject into the ground. Mayweather also tells every fighter he has faced since Oscar De La Hoya that he is “willing to die in the ring”. Yet, he claims that his “health is the most important thing” in a recent interview. Mayweather continues to forget what excuse he is currently using to avoid a Pacquiao fight, continues to contradict himself, and makes himself look extremely foolish while doing it. Finally, Mayweather criticized Pacquaio for catchweight fights, but never mentions that he himself fought Juan Manuel Marquez at a catchweight.
Despite*Cotto’s gallant effort, he clearly lost the bout. Anyone that claims differently simply doesn’t know what they are watching. After the official scorecards were read, Cotto left the ring in disgust and denied HBO a post-fight interview. Cotto also refused to show up at the post-fight press conference. HBO’s Jim Lampley*suggested that Cotto went to the back immediately after the fight because he had to use the bathroom. Then at the post-fight press conference, Richard Schaefer of Golden Boy Promotions claimed that Cotto wouldn’t be attending the press conference because he had gone to the hospital.* Both of the claims seem to be bogus as Cotto posted that he was in the sky loft with his family and that he respects the judges’ decision but he disagrees with them. Once again, I don’t want to take anything away from Cotto’s performance; he showed tremendous will and heart. But, he clearly lost. I scored the fight 117-111 for Mayweather, giving Cotto rounds*three, six and eight. It is possible that round*five could’ve gone to him as well but that would be it. Cotto won four rounds at most during the fight, and is acting like a sore loser and extremely unprofessional, as he wasn’t robbed. Mayweather clearly won an extremely competitive fight. .
*
THE AFTERMATH?
Now that Mayweather had some hard moments against Cotto, many are once again wondering how he would match up against Manny Pacquiao? I had a long, detailed conversation with **********'s Stephen “Breadman” Edwards on Sunday morning about this and there are many arguments for both sides. It is evident*Mayweather was susceptible to left hands, whether*thrown by an orthodox fighter in the form of a jab or*by a southpaw in the form of a power punch. Pacquiao’s straight left*is*harder* than Cotto’s left jab, and Mayweather might be dealing with a little more than a bloody nose if he was to be hit with Pacquiao’s version of the two. However, Cotto’s success on Saturday night occurred when he bullied Mayweather and pushed him into the ropes. Cotto would corner Mayweather, not let him escape, and then flurry. Would the naturally smaller Pacquiao be able to do that to Mayweather? Styles make fights and no assumptions should be made about how either Mayweather or Pacquiao would perform against one another solely based on their past performances against*Marquez and*Cotto.
Marquez fights differently than Mayweather and Cotto fights differently than Pacquiao. For now, Mayweather is flirting with the idea of retiring. I know, we have heard that many times before but this time he may be genuine, as his bloody nose showed the boxing world that he may be declining on Saturday night. Nevertheless, the demand for a mega-fight between Mayweather and Pacquiao may now be stronger than ever as both men have showed*vulnerability in their last outings.
Send questions and comments to: jmccormick43@aol.com