Comments Thread For: Argenis Mendez' Team To Appeal Barthelemy KO Outcome

[ElMeroChingon]

In Tyson's words" F*** it it's a fight ! "

Difference being your going went into the ring with intentions to cheat! Premeditated

I got this fool talking about Margarito, sounds like you already too a knee for Barth heh

Only difference is that Tyson did bite someone's ear off .
Margarito never cheated bro, get your facts straight.

[Levity]

The KO punch was clearly after the bell, and regardless of whether he heard the bell or not, or whether it was a mistake or not, he won with a blow that is illegal according to the rules.

The result shouldn't stand just because Bathelemy was dominating after about 2 rounds; plenty of fighters come back from very shaky moments early in fights, and 2 very good rounds for Barthelemy does not mean that he would've won or that he should be allowed to win with illegal blows.

[Respect Power]

The guy in your avatar "BIT someone's ear off", barth should've choked him on the ground, after all he was going through "emotions".
lol

What's your argument again?

[BarnBurnerBrawl]

I got this fool talking about Margarito, sounds like you already too a knee for Barth heh

Only difference is that Tyson did bite someone's ear off .
Margarito never cheated bro, get your facts straight.

Tell cotto that !

[CubanGuyNYC]

Oh yeah, Mendez better hope they just deny him anything involving a rematch, so he can move onto fights he has chance at winning.

That was a brutal beatdown given to him with ease.

I was bordering on shock. I expected Rances to win, but nothing like that easily. The first good shot Argenis took wobbled him. Then Bart knocked him down twice in the following round, the last one for good. I've never seen Rances look so sharp. He must be so glad to have gotten rid of John David Jackson (who is now with Mendez) as his trainer. lol

[CubanGuyNYC]

The KO punch was clearly after the bell, and regardless of whether he heard the bell or not, or whether it was a mistake or not, he won with a blow that is illegal according to the rules.

The result shouldn't stand just because Bathelemy was dominating after about 2 rounds; plenty of fighters come back from very shaky moments early in fights, and 2 very good rounds for Barthelemy does not mean that he would've won or that he should be allowed to win with illegal blows.

I agree with everything you wrote. So what should be done about the illegal KO punch?

[DannYankee]

DQ, NC, whatever. Mendez should not have lost on a foul. But how can you call throwing punches "unintentional" or accidental.

Also who cares if the combo started before the bell? What if a fighter wanted to throw a 100 punch combo, that would be ok, even if the bell rang after the 1st punch? The punches that KO'd him were after the bell

It's boxing throwing punches relentlessly is what they do it ain't ping pong that's why low blows can be "unintentionall" or intentional you thinking about a fight like they are playing golf or something let's see you stop yourself in the middle of throwing 4 punches in a sport where the smallest of errors can get you put to sleep. If you start throwing punches is not as easy to stop in the span of a second as you make it sound like it's a switch, and that's why its the damn ref's job to stop the action at the bell and alert the fighters to stop at the bell as well.

Also something else that is the ref responsibility is judge fouls as he sees them he judged the blows where still in the heat of the action Barth was throwing his combo Mendez had his guard 100% up and got ktfo that's why probably why he deemed it legal.

[IIG]

I don't find it egregious enough to overturn. The ref didn't step in, and it's reasonable to believe that a bloodthirsty Barthelemy was more focused on his combination than listening for the bell. I weigh these on a case by case basis, and this one falls under protect yourself at all times.

[.:: JSFD26 ::.]

I wonder if the ref could've given him 5-10 minutes to recover and let Bart finish what he had started.

Lol I know you're trying to be funny and all but did you see Mendez do the PEDerson? I think he would've needed a week, not 5 mins.

I shouldn't be laughing tho. I ****s with Mendez.


Posted from Boxingscene.com App for Android

[.:: JSFD26 ::.]

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cu****uyNYC

How much do you wanna bet the KO stands? lol

The commissions almost never overturns rulings. They didnt even overturn the fake DQ when Cortez said Humberto Soto punched Francisco Lorenzo when he was down and video clearly showed the punched didnt land

That doesnt mean its right that Mendez gets KO'd after the bell. But he's Cuban, so u have to support him i guesss

This dude is such a fkin clown. As bad as the race baiters.

Cu****uy out of everybody...


Posted from Boxingscene.com App for Android