Why is Toney so underrated here?
He seems to get the recognition he deserves when we talk about skills, but career wise, I would rank him just as high as Jones and Hopkins on the all time list.
Toney’s best wins:
Michael Nunn
Mike McCallum 2x
Iran Barkley
Vassiliy Jirov
Evander Holyfield
Jones’ Best wins:
Bernard Hopkins
James Toney
Montel Griffin
Virgil Hill
John Ruiz
Antonio Tarver
Hopkins’ best wins
Glen Johnson
Felix Trinidad
Oscar De La Hoya
Antonio Tarver
Winky Wright
Kelly Pavlik
Now consider, when they fought their competition, and the weight class they fought them at.
Toney’s best wins in my opinion edge out Roy’s and blows Hopkin’s resume out the water.
Looking at Hopkin’s best wins, it really puts things in perspective, almost all his best wins, he had a noticeable size advantage, aside from Tarver and Glen Johnson. Hopkins definitely deserves credit for his longevity in the sport, and being the oldest champion of all time, but his resume is lacking.
Roy’s resume is better, and he has two prime all time greats on his list, yes I know some of you are going to say Hopkins wasn’t in his prime yet, but everyone saids that without merit. He was on a 22 fight win streak before Roy, and a 25 fight win streak after Roy, and he gave Roy one of his toughest fights at in his prime. But other than those two fights, Roy being the man for about 15 years, didn’t take enough risky fights, and settled on mandatories.Roy not fighting Dariusz Michalczewski really hurts his resume in my opinion. Theres a lot of articles, and stories on who was to blame, but nevertheless, it should have been made.
Head to head, I can’t see how anyone wouldn’t rank James right along, with Roy, and higher than Hopkins.