would prime JC Chavez Sr beat Floyd Mayweather

[Mexican_Puppet]

I think Floyd destroys Chavez Sr, but I am a huge Floyd fan so clearly I am biased.

Those looking at the Castillo, Maidana and Cotto fights need to remember each man was significantly heavier than Floyd in that fight. I don't know that Chavez Sr. would be the bigger man if he fought Floyd.

Chavez was stronger than Castillo, Maidana and Cotto, way better and stronger.

Chavez destroyed the life of Taylor.

And was made of steel, in his prime was unstoppable in 3 different divisions, was a tank, good defense, good pressing and great IQ to cut the ring, the best game inside of the history in boxing, great hook to the body and combinations.

Will be a hell of a fight.

Floyd never faced a guy like JCC.

[djtmal]

50/50

floyd is disciplined enough to outbox chavez for 12, but damn that chavez...it don't look like he's doing much, but at the end of 12 the other guy is a bloody, puffy pulp...war of atttrition favors chavez if floyd decides to be more offensive

[therealpugilist]

Would early 1990s Chavez Sr beat late 2000s Floyd Mayweather at 140lbs or 147lbs or even better a catchweight at 144lbs....

Nope, PBF wins


Mayweather has better boxing skills is taller longer with better stamina than meldrick Taylor

He is as elusive as Whitaker n can fight inside

JCC gets outpointed in a 8-4 type fight

[djtmal]

Nope, PBF wins


Mayweather has better boxing skills is taller longer with better stamina than meldrick Taylor

He is as elusive as Whitaker n can fight inside

JCC gets outpointed in a 8-4 type fight

mike tyson doesn't have a chance either...lol

[The Big Dunn]

Chavez was stronger than Castillo, Maidana and Cotto, way better and stronger.

Chavez destroyed the life of Taylor.

And was made of steel, in his prime was unstoppable in 3 different divisions, was a tank, good defense, good pressing and great IQ to cut the ring, the best game inside of the history in boxing, great hook to the body and combinations.

Will be a hell of a fight.

Floyd never faced a guy like JCC.

Maybe Castillo, but Maidana and Cotto I don't know.

Taylor is an interesting point. Taylor could've fought differently but he kept putting himself in harms way and lost the fight by stoppage, a stoppage that still gets discussed.

I am sure Chavez brings a lot of things to the table that Floyd would have to deal with. But Floyd would have a significant speed advantage and you can't discount his reach. Very few boxers from 130-147 have the long arms that Floyd does. Those that do don't always use the reach effectively.

we will obviously never know but the whitaker/chavez fight IMO gives us a good idea. even if you go with chavez/taylor Taylor dominated most of that fight and easily would've won if he fought "with a lead" the way we expect Floyd to.

[therealpugilist]

Chavez was stronger than Castillo, Maidana and Cotto, way better and stronger.

Chavez destroyed the life of Taylor.

And was made of steel, in his prime was unstoppable in 3 different divisions, was a tank, good defense, good pressing and great IQ to cut the ring, the best game inside of the history in boxing, great hook to the body and combinations.

Will be a hell of a fight.

Floyd never faced a guy like JCC.

Jcc never faced a fighter like Floyd

He got a gift draw vs Whitaker n gift stoppage of Taylor with seconds left after being outboxed at least 8 rounds to 3

Frankie Randall outboxed him as well and he could have lost to Juan laporte and rocky lock ridge

JCC was not stronger than maidana and cotto ...he was a greater fighter tho....these guys were strong at welter whereas JCC never looked good past 140 nor very strong. Also he fought most of his career @ 135 or less n maidana n cotto were @ their prime as solid ww coming in @ 160+ fight night

JCC looked inept vs every elite rhythmic boxer he fought n was lucky not to have a few loses. Mayweather is far better than all of them.except sweet pea

[therealpugilist]

mike tyson doesn't have a chance either...lol

you do realize mayweather beat better opposition, won titles in more divisions and started at 130 just like JCC

its pretty pathetic considering how many of you criticize his resume and opposition and he clearly beat better opposition and accomplished more than chavez...try to dispute it....you cant

not my problem you dislike Mayweather and have disdain for him.


when someone has no rebuttal, they usually reply with a joke or insult...good job exposing yourself....keep sippin the haterade.

[therealpugilist]

stylistically Sr beats FLoyd. Floyd's style CAN be smothered but he's never fought an elite smothering fighter like Sr to an even lesser extent Margarito.

Maidana and Castillo showed this and they are B-C class swarmers.

lay off the meth man


margarito couldnt carry Castillo's jock strap....Far more skilled than 'Cheato and beat better opposition in his career.

anybody can be smothered but was he beaten? nope....the one close fight he had, he won the rematch clearer.....i know you forget their was a rematch bwahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha

[djtmal]

you do realize mayweather beat better opposition, won titles in more divisions and started at 130 just like JCC

its pretty pathetic considering how many of you criticize his resume and opposition and he clearly beat better opposition and accomplished more than chavez...try to dispute it....you cant

not my problem you dislike Mayweather and have disdain for him.


when someone has no rebuttal, they usually reply with a joke or insult...good job exposing yourself....keep sippin the haterade.

rebuttal...

hatton, corrales, and alvarez,..floyd's best wins over prime fighters and prime jcc doesn't trump these guys?

prime jcc destroyed a prime roger mayweather, and has a prime meldrick taylor...ruined him, and floyd beats him 8-4?...gtfoh

i am exposing how you ****ride

[The Big Dunn]

rebuttal...

hatton, corrales, and alvarez,..floyd's best wins over prime fighters and prime jcc doesn't trump these guys?

prime jcc destroyed a prime roger mayweather, and has a prime meldrick taylor...ruined him, and floyd beats him 8-4?...gtfoh

i am exposing how you ****ride

You are not being honest about the Taylor fight. He was well ahead and the stoppage was questionable. Chavez gets all the credit for continuing to work and fighting like a possessed beast determined to win but please be more honest about what happened.