would prime JC Chavez Sr beat Floyd Mayweather

[The Big Dunn]

I think Floyd destroys Chavez Sr, but I am a huge Floyd fan so clearly I am biased.

Those looking at the Castillo, Maidana and Cotto fights need to remember each man was significantly heavier than Floyd in that fight. I don't know that Chavez Sr. would be the bigger man if he fought Floyd.

[TX_BOXNG]

Lol if Castillo beat Pretty Boy, imagine The Legend on him

[Scary]

Yes, on robbery. Elsewhere I believe Floyd would win most rounds and make it look simple.

[buckfuddy]

No, JCC is a mythical legend and all, but Floyd is too much for him

[MikeLazcan]

it all depends on how floyd fights, if he fights conservative like in the second maidana fight he'd outbox chavez, someone to really test floyd would be Lara, he's fought chavez style many times

[Johnny2x2x]

Floyd takes apart a prime Sr. But I just don't think Chavez Senior was all that great. Made his name fighting club fighters. Had some decent wins vs good fighters, but got the benefit on a few he should have lost.

Mayweather makes easy work of Sr. at any weight.

Duran is the only fighter 135-140 that probably beats Floyd.

[MikeLazcan]

Floyd takes apart a prime Sr. But I just don't think Chavez Senior was all that great. Made his name fighting club fighters. Had some decent wins vs good fighters, but got the benefit on a few he should have lost.

Mayweather makes easy work of Sr. at any weight.

Duran is the only fighter 135-140 that probably beats Floyd.

agree with this

[buckfuddy]

Duran is the only fighter 135-140 that probably beats Floyd.

Floyd is great, but Duran is the best in 135 ever. Also young Sweat Pea and The Hawk won't be underdogs in my book.

Btw: Floyd vs Meldrick would be helluva fight also

[Mexican_Puppet]

Maidana and cotto examples are ****** then cause floyd was out of his prime

Maybe...

But the careers were differents, Floyd had a swift career and was very disciplined, for his style he doesn't took much punches.

The point is that is a reality that JCC vs Withaker(in welterweight) and Randall was out of his prime. That's totally evident.

[Mexican_Puppet]

Please let the "prime" word die soon. One of the most overused terms in boxing

Imagine that you are a sportsman. You will be the same at 25 or 34?

The fighters are not robots, they have their primes. And in a fantasy fight we have to imagine in that moment.