would prime JC Chavez Sr beat Floyd Mayweather

[MELLY-MEL...]

Yes he can

[Mexican_Puppet]

It was evident with Floyd aswell..cant use the excuse for once and ignore the other

With Castillo was in prime.

[King Jaffe Joffer]

Would be target practice for Floyd. Pot shot Sr to death

[bigdunny1]

Nope it would look like whitaker/chavez. Easy for Floyd.

[djtmal]

Yep, talk about beating out of prime, weight drained, and guys who already had the **** kicked out of them (several by floyd) first.

Too bad the Floyd boys can't put the word "prime", next to his wins over Pac, Cotto, and Oldsley, but they will sell it to you like you buying a fresh off the lot Bentley.

[A.K]

So I take it most of you never seen Chavez schooled by pernell in his prime Floyd would win every round as well.

[Left Hook Tua]

My mind always says Mayweather in this match up, but it wasn't a coincidence the success of Maidana, Cotto and Castillo using pressure against Floyd, Chavez was better than all of them.

Castillo had success

Maidana had a little success

Cotto had no success

[Left Hook Tua]

So I take it most of you never seen Chavez schooled by pernell in his prime Floyd would win every round as well.

Floyd isn't as good as pernell

Chavez is way better than castillo

[LoadedWraps]

Would early 1990s Chavez Sr beat late 2000s Floyd Mayweather at 140lbs or 147lbs or even better a catchweight at 144lbs....

Of course not.

Any version of Floyd beats any version of JCC Sr. Floyd is better at everything and can match his stamina.

At least you stepped your troll level game up to a D- though.

[A.K]

Floyd isn't as good as pernell

Chavez is way better than castillo

No but his defense is and Chavez would still be too slow to catch him.