Hagler vs James Toney MW WAR

[IronDanHamza]

I cant tell you becouse Tony had no similar opponent to Hagler,and Hagler had no opponent like Toney i based my opinion on styles .

But Hagler showed his ability against elite competition.

The best only elite fighter Toney "beat" was McCallum and I use the term "beat" loosely on that one.

Toney never showed he was on Hagler's level.

[Canelo and GGG]

But Hagler showed his ability against elite competition.

The best only elite fighter Toney "beat" was McCallum and I use the term "beat" loosely on that one.

Toney never showed he was on Hagler's level.

Ok i know what you mean now i still thing thjat it wouldnt be easy and it would be good fight

Hagler had good comp ,better then tony for sure.

Why Tony vs Euban or Hopkins or Michalczewski never happended ? im to young i watched this fighters on youtube and Espn classic but i dont get bisneus side of 90s

Btw now i diged deeper and Hagler beat Roy johns jr's Father? LMAO so many history in one resume.

[Elroy The Great]

hagler. imho, he was the more complete fighter.

[champion4ever]

At 160, Hagler wins hands down. Aside from the Michael Nunn KO, James Toney was pretty much average at 160; Where he was beginning to show the first signs of a lack of discipline, dedication, commitment and professionalism to the sport of boxing.

James' training and nutrition habits, were eerily similar to that of one Roberto Duran's. He loved to party and would often let himself go between fights to the point, of frequently being plagued by both conditioning and weight issues. Not only in that particular weight class but for throughout most of his boxing career as well.

On the other hand, Marvin was the hungrier, more focused and disciplined of the two. He was very diligent and professional in his approach to the game because it was his livelihood.

[bojangles1987]

Toney was absolutely not more skilled than Hagler.

Hagler by very clear decision.

[bojangles1987]

Toney by clear UD, it would be a real war tho

I think Toney also.

HOW?

Normally I'd let IronDan do this but we're talking Marvin Hagler here. How the hell does James Toney beat Marvin Hagler? What advantage does he have?

[Canelo and GGG]

HOW?

Normally I'd let IronDan do this but we're talking Marvin Hagler here. How the hell does James Toney beat Marvin Hagler? What advantage does he have?

read thread i was talking about it with Dan ,we are both staying on our picks,Hagler was never something special for me ,he was not on SRR or Monzon lvl ,just my opinion,i think RJJ would beat Marvin wide too .

[bojangles1987]

read thread i was talking about it with Dan ,we are both staying on our picks,Hagler was never something special for me ,he was not on SRR or Monzon lvl ,just my opinion,i think RJJ would beat Marvin wide too .

Okay, Jones beating Hagler wide means nothing regarding a Toney fight. James Toney is nowhere near Roy Jones's level.

If Hagler is nothing special, then Toney is a bum. Toney lost to average and sometimes awful fighters. He never beat anyone worthwhile in a convincing way. Everyone good he fought, he struggled or got his ass kicked.

[Canelo and GGG]

Okay, Jones beating Hagler wide means nothing regarding a Toney fight. James Toney is nowhere near Roy Jones's level.

If Hagler is nothing special, then Toney is a bum. Toney lost to average and sometimes awful fighters. He never beat anyone worthwhile in a convincing way. Everyone good he fought, he struggled or got his ass kicked.

maybe i over used nothing special here ,not a goat like SRR or Monzon,just good HoFer ,i can see him winning with Toney i just see Tonys counter punching giving him edge on points,if Hagler can Move and box well for 12 rounds like Sugar ray leanard he can win easy but i cant see that.

[Canelo and GGG]

Okay, Jones beating Hagler wide means nothing regarding a Toney fight. James Toney is nowhere near Roy Jones's level.

If Hagler is nothing special, then Toney is a bum. Toney lost to average and sometimes awful fighters. He never beat anyone worthwhile in a convincing way. Everyone good he fought, he struggled or got his ass kicked.

I dont rate Toney higher over all i just think its good matchup for him ,you get me bro?