Is Danny Garcias resume now better then Hattons?

[IronDanHamza]

I did say:



But I believe that was only because people started bringing Terrible's name up.

Judah? Really? I don't even remember last time he won a legitimate fight.

You just included Castillo a few pages ago.

[-Huey-]

Yeah. Hatton's only notable win was Tzyu....kinda like Margarito's only meaningful win was against Cotto, although it was a tainted win due to the loaded gloves...

[LacedUp]

You just included Castillo a few pages ago.

Because you or someone else included Morales!

regardless, it wasn't meant to go down as a "top" win for Ricky, I believed I just rolled out the big names he fought.

[junior gong]

Freddie Pendleton? Come on.

Thaxton, Magee, these aren't good wins at all.

Ricky Hatton pretty much did nothing of note between 2000-2004 when holding his paper belt hostage.

Really?? Are they not? Its clear I'm talking to a 'top trumper' here. Both were very solid, tough fighters. Carry on tho lad. You're comparing a young champion who has just got going to someone who had a career nearly twice as long. Herp dip dip derp.

[LacedUp]

He was coming off the Paris fight that he was expected to lose.

Judah is definitely better than the vast majority of Hatton's wins.

He was 16-17 years into a war torn career when he fought Danny. He was done.

[IronDanHamza]

Because you or someone else included Morales!

regardless, it wasn't meant to go down as a "top" win for Ricky, I believed I just rolled out the big names he fought.

It has nothing to do with Morales.

You said Danny has two top wins and nothing else whilst Hatton has a long list of solid wins and including Castillo on that list.

You didn't say anything about Morales in that statment you didn't say "If you include Morales you have to include Castillo" you were just stating the difference between Garcia's and Hatton's resume in your opinion.

[IronDanHamza]

He was 16-17 years into a war torn career when he fought Danny. He was done.

How was he done? Based off what?

[IronDanHamza]

Really?? Are they not? Its clear I'm talking to a 'top trumper' here. Both were very solid, tough fighters. Carry on tho lad. You're comparing a young champion who has just got going to someone who had a career nearly twice as long. Herp dip dip derp.

So you consider his WBU run as an actual run?

None of those fighters were ranked. You're actually including Pendleton which is hilarious

How are those fighters solid wins at those particular times? Explain that to me.

I can understand his work from 05-08, that was very solid work. That's where Hatton built his career. That is Hatton's career basically.

[LacedUp]

It has nothing to do with Morales.

You said Danny has two top wins and nothing else whilst Hatton has a long list of solid wins and including Castillo on that list.

You didn't say anything about Morales in that statment you didn't say "If you include Morales you have to include Castillo" you were just stating the difference between Garcia's and Hatton's resume in your opinion.

No, but I started out in the thread by saying "depending how you rate Castillo for that fight, you could include him as well" - I also said, "At least Castillo was on a run of wins".

Regardless, that's what it was meant to say. Hatton doesn't have many elite wins, but he has Tszuy and his second tier wins are stronger than Danny's at this moment in time, and that's all there is to it.

How was he done? Based off what?

Why he was done? Is that a serious question? He was in wars with Barrera, was KTFO by Pacquiao or quit or whatever you want to call twice (and people were saying Pacquiao knocked out a past prime Morales!). Then he fights 6 times in six years, struggling to make weight and looking grossly out of shape compared to what he did in his prime.

Admittedly, he gave Maidana a good fight and won against Cano, but other than there was nothing. He was quite clearly not the same fighter he once was.

[junior gong]

So you consider his WBU run as an actual run?

None of those fighters were ranked. You're actually including Pendleton which is hilarious

How are those fighters solid wins at those particular times? Explain that to me.

I can understand his work from 05-08, that was very solid work. That's where Hatton built his career. That is Hatton's career basically.

So everything else he did is completely irrelevant? Got it!

Gotta love NSB!