Is Danny Garcias resume now better then Hattons?

[AntonTheMeh]

kostya was old and half retired, but he was the lineal champ. at best mathysse was the uncrowned king at 140. i say it's fairly close.

[Larry the boss]

Are you suggesting that Lucas Matthysse is on par with Kostya Tyszu?

Yes,Lucas was prime and not old and injured

[Dirk Diggler UK]

Yes,Lucas was prime and not old and injured

You're an idiot

[Larry the boss]

You're an idiot

was he not old??was he not coming back from an injury after a long break??he he not past prime?? who was his best win that makes him so great? sure he was lineal but he was old injured and way past prime,plus one win doesnt erase the next mans entire resume..is Marquez greater then Manny since his ko over Manny is better then anything on Mannys resume? is Buster Douglass greater then Tyson since his ko over tyson is better then anything on tysons resume?

[Danny Gunz]

You're an idiot

[Dirk Diggler UK]

was he not old??was he not coming back from an injury after a long break??he he not past prime?? who was his best win that makes him so great? sure he was lineal but he was old injured and way past prime

He was in the top 3 Pound for Pound fighters in the world. And he was younger than Mayweather, Marquez and Martinez are now.

He had injury problems but he came back and blew out Sharmba Mitchell in 3 rounds before he faced Hatton. Mitchell was one of the top fighters at 140 at the time and someone who gave him a little trouble in their first fight.

Hatton was a huge underdog in the fight. I'm not talking Garcia-Matthysse odds either.

[puga]

Better start overrating Danny now so when the Floyd fight is signed he can be passed off as a legitimate opponent.

exactly the reason why this thread was created....not sayin it aint a legit fight on paper...angel garcia vs team floyd would really be somthing, lol

[Dirk Diggler UK]

Ok?

I'm not even knocking Garcia. I've started to really admire Danny but to say a win over Matthysse ranks with a win over Kostya Tszyu is just ******ity.

Matthysse barely beat a 2010 version of Zab which tells its own story.

[LacedUp]

Tszyu win >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Entire Garcia resume.

This was my first thought too.

Hatton has more wins and more better wins. Khan and Matthysse are good wins, but are they better wins than Tszuy, Malignaggi, Castillo, Urango etc? No.

So he's still got some time to go, but it's possible.

[FrankieBruno]

Not yet, but if he puts together wins over some more top names then yes