As of right now who ranks higher,Floyd or Manny

[SpArKeD-CoLd]

Its Floyd, its always been him. I love pacquioa hes a menace but he dont deserve to be number 1... Floyd is the only fighter in boxing who matters to me.. He is the king

[Jam Jars]

its floyd, its always been him. I love pacquioa hes a menace but he dont deserve to be number 1... floyd is the only fighter in boxing who matters to me.. He is the king

wtf................

[KiloTeague]

So why does Pacquiao have a better resume than floyd and why was Pacquiao named fighter of the decade by BWAA and Ring Magazine and not floyd?

Pac fought life and death 3 times and got K.Oed the fourth time by a guy that Floyd basically shut out. There resume's are virtually equal. There records against those resume's are not. If you fight the best people, and loose every fight, can you say that guy has the best resume?

Manny is a beast don't get me wrong. But Floyd is better.

[The Noose]

Shocked at the poll.

Im a Floyd hater, but i dont see how Pac can be ranked higher than him. I have always supported Pac, but i had him losing all the JMM fights. Floyd is still p4p the best. Pac had his moment.

[straightleft]

Greatness is about accomplishment and resume. Not about losses and being undefeated. All high ranking ATGs suffered a few losses on their career but still considered on top for what they did not because they were skilled and undefeated.. Floyd is just like Calzaghe but at least Calzaghe fought all he needs to fight.

Floyd faking his retirement to duck young prime fighters in his own divisions, self confessed cherry picker and coward, weight cheating, sucker punching and catchweight king a sure way to beat Pac accomplishments.

Pac beating prime Barrera and prime Marquez without the weight cheating s*h*t on Floyd lame resume. If you are so good why Pac did so much better against their 5 common opponents? Floyd lame claim to the throne is because he is undefeated but once Canelo ko him for good or other fighter ko him for good. He will drop down hard like a crashing airplane. You know why? because he has no great accomplishment but lame resume to back up his claim. Beating the great Baldomir, ATG Gatti, Super Judah, Mega Guerrero is a sure way resume to beat Pac in ranking.

[hugh grant]

Pac after beating Barrera was for 7 years just a fighter, fighting top names and opponents, regularly. That is just tough on the body, and Pac prevailed mostly with only a slight hiccup here and there.

Floyd since he became a name or a somebody, has coasted and had the luxury of lay offs and cherry pick and has really been under no pressure doing as he pleases when he wants. Even BH can do what Floyd does.

Pac is basically fighting 3 times to Floyds once. You cant compare what Pac did to Floyd. It actually don't mean nothing that Floyd looks quite good when he actually does fight. It really don't.

[Pacdbest]

Pac after beating Barrera was for 7 years just a fighter, fighting top names and opponents, regularly. That is just tough on the body, and Pac prevailed mostly with only a slight hiccup here and there.

Floyd since he became a name or a somebody, has coasted and had the luxury of lay offs and cherry pick and has really been under no pressure doing as he pleases when he wants. Even BH can do what Floyd does.

Pac is basically fighting 3 times to Floyds once. You cant compare what Pac did to Floyd. It actually don't mean nothing that Floyd looks quite good when he actually does fight. It really don't.

Pac left Floyd behind when Floyd starts ducking Pac! I hope Canelo ends His Ducking!

[SoulByThePound]

Who cares at the OP

[The Big Dunn]

Greatness is about accomplishment and resume. Not about losses and being undefeated. All high ranking ATGs suffered a few losses on their career but still considered on top for what they did not because they were skilled and undefeated.. Floyd is just like Calzaghe but at least Calzaghe fought all he needs to fight.

Floyd faking his retirement to duck young prime fighters in his own divisions, self confessed cherry picker and coward, weight cheating, sucker punching and catchweight king a sure way to beat Pac accomplishments.

Pac beating prime Barrera and prime Marquez without the weight cheating s*h*t on Floyd lame resume. If you are so good why Pac did so much better against their 5 common opponents? Floyd lame claim to the throne is because he is undefeated but once Canelo ko him for good or other fighter ko him for good. He will drop down hard like a crashing airplane. You know why? because he has no great accomplishment but lame resume to back up his claim. Beating the great Baldomir, ATG Gatti, Super Judah, Mega Guerrero is a sure way resume to beat Pac in ranking.

Pac after beating Barrera was for 7 years just a fighter, fighting top names and opponents, regularly. That is just tough on the body, and Pac prevailed mostly with only a slight hiccup here and there.

Floyd since he became a name or a somebody, has coasted and had the luxury of lay offs and cherry pick and has really been under no pressure doing as he pleases when he wants. Even BH can do what Floyd does.

Pac is basically fighting 3 times to Floyds once. You cant compare what Pac did to Floyd. It actually don't mean nothing that Floyd looks quite good when he actually does fight. It really don't.

Pac left Floyd behind when Floyd starts ducking Pac! I hope Canelo ends His Ducking!

Boys, its ok. You can't live off 1998 and 2001 forever. Manny beat Ledbawa and he beat MAB twice. Great wins. He lost to ATG Morales and only beat him after Zahir Raheem did. He beat Hatton, Mosley, ODH after Floyd. He beat Cotto at 145 and Margs at 151. The majority of writers/media felt he lost the 2nd and 3rd fights to JMM.

He is a 1st ballot HOF'er, FOTD, FOTY and china's #2 star. He's just not better than Floyd.

[the_ilest]

http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/sh...d.php?t=441538

Floyd's best win is diego corrales and he has yet to face a legit HOF fighter in their prime.

Easily pacquiao.

floyd beat marquez a hof in his prime. pac could not even beat marquez decisively.

floyd over pac.