As of right now who ranks higher,Floyd or Manny

[flat1985]

LOL at people still using Ring p4p rankings when they are owned by golden boy hahaha. Anyway i think Floyd would beat Manny prime for prime quite comfortably but Manny has the better top wins imo.

[Jc8804]

Floyd faught coming off a loss zab
,small marquez (scale cheated),
Quitter ortiz,
Lame ghost, and inexperienced canelo.
Old shane off a huge layoff????
Floyd never beat a prime hall of famer .
Paul williams , margarito, pacman and kostya
Were all waiting for a call, floyd ran to vacation and retirement.
Legacy sealed

[JOM'S]

are we talking p4p or their position on ATG list, if the former easily floyd, if the latter IMHO it is still Pac, heck even if floyd & Pac fight and jr beat the crap out of Manny, it will still be arguable who is on top of the ATG list...

[Larry the boss]

LOL at people still using Ring p4p rankings when they are owned by golden boy hahaha. Anyway i think Floyd would beat Manny prime for prime quite comfortably but Manny has the better top wins imo.

I listed both top wins..how does Manny win?

Floyd faught coming off a loss zab
,small marquez (scale cheated),
Quitter ortiz,
Lame ghost, and inexperienced canelo.
Old shane off a huge layoff????
Floyd never beat a prime hall of famer .
Paul williams , margarito, pacman and kostya
Were all waiting for a call, floyd ran to vacation and retirement.
Legacy sealed

Ok Manny GOT KO'D by that same small Marquez
fougth an EVEN OLDR NONE CHAMPION MOSLEY
Is fighting a small 0 fights a ww none elite Rios
Lost to Bradley who was unranked at ww
never fought Paul Williams..and Fought AN UNRANKED COMING OFF OF A BRUTAL KO AND A SUSPENSION MARGO AT A 150 CATCHWEIGHT FOR A VACANT MADE UP TITLE
Hasnt fought a damn ww since 2011 and hasnt fought a ww champion since 2009


How can you down floyd and big up manny??it is impossible

since 2009 floyd has face the
#1 154 fighter(cotto)
the 154 champ(canelo)
the #2 ww-2 times-(guerrero,ortiz
the #1 (lineal)ww(Mosley)

Manny has faced

the #2 ww (cotto)2009


and thats it

[Larry the boss]

are we talking p4p or their position on ATG list, if the former easily floyd, if the latter IMHO it is still Pac, heck even if floyd & Pac fight and jr beat the crap out of Manny, it will still be arguable who is on top of the ATG list...

I am talking ATG and Floyd resume is better and if they fight and Floyd wins(which he would easily) there is no damn argument at all..how do ya'll come up with this **** like Manny beat Ali or something? Barerra had a metal plate in his damn head and Morales beat him the 1st time..Manny only wins over Morales came off of Morales losses...

[Larry the boss]

It is time to keep it real..i even said after Manny beat Cotto his resume was better then Floyd..but now???HELL NO!!!