As of right now who ranks higher,Floyd or Manny

[IronDanHamza]

what do u mean by the bold?

I mean Mayweather was the much smaller fighter when they fought.

[B Phontain]

I mean Mayweather was the much smaller fighter when they fought.

oh ok, Which is crazy bc in this era of shrink down to blow up fighters,mayweather has pretty much always been the smaller fighter. i think he believes it helps him somehow

[Humean]

All in all I find it hard to split them at this stage. They are both certainly the two greatest fighters of their era. What would have split it is if they had fought.

[PAC-BOY]

As far as I'm aware De La Hoya has nothing to do with the P4P rankings or the Magazine in general.

im sure that's what he wants everyone to think. Now just think back to when he bought it. Floyd was still retired. He came out of retirement and fought JMM. Controversy from the start. JMM moving up from 3 weight classes having only one fight at 135. (Floyd wasn't anywhere in the top P4P ratings). Floyd didn't make weight. The CW. Was fined 600k to award it to JMM. Floyd didn't get on the unofficial scales on fight night. Blah blah blah...Beats his SFW/LW opponent and out of the blue....ends up tied with Manny as the best #1 P4P fighter...by Ring ratings! hmmmmmm

Thats working your way back to the top!:WORD:

[IronDanHamza]

im sure that's what he wants everyone to think. Now just think back to when he bought it. Floyd was still retired. He came out of retirement and fought JMM. Controversy from the start. JMM moving up from 3 weight classes having only one fight at 135. (Floyd wasn't anywhere in the top P4P ratings). Floyd didn't make weight. The CW. Was fined 600k to award it to JMM. Floyd didn't get on the unofficial scales on fight night. Blah blah blah...Beats his SFW/LW opponent and out of the blue....ends up tied with Manny as the best #1 P4P fighter...by Ring ratings! hmmmmmm

Thats working your way back to the top!:WORD:

He wasn't tied with Pacquaio until 2011/2012.

Pacquaio was P4P #1 between 2008-2011.

[Sosay]

They're both atg's. There's only like 6 atg in the game. May, Pac, BHop, Marquez, & the KBros. I rank the first three on a higher tier than the next three, but none of them are "that" far apart. No need to hate on one to boost the other one up.

[JaYDeuce11]

YOu have to be a big hater or delusional pacfan to think Pacquiao is greater than Mayweather at the moment...Im a huge HUGE Pacquiao fan, but i admitt Mayweather is greater
The whole hype around the Mayweather Pacquiao fight was if Pacquiao can be the 1 to finally beat Mayqeather. Not if Mayweather can beat Pacquiao
after all these years, Mayweather has maintained his level/no one has threatened him in a fight, but Pacquiao has declined each fight by fight then the KO by Marquez. Its great to climb to the top, but you also have to maintain it which Mayweather has done and pacquiao has now failed

[HeroBando]

As far as I'm aware De La Hoya has nothing to do with the P4P rankings or the Magazine in general.

No, only Chuck Giampa does. Come on man, you can recognize this transparent move: take out the panel and entrust it to one guy so it's easy to disown any responsibility. You think it's a coincidence each Floyd opponent gets ranked p4p? Canelo's 2nd best win is still a shot Mosley, worse than the guy graded F here by many posters as a Pac win.

[IronDanHamza]

No, only Chuck Giampa does. Come on man, you can recognize this transparent move: take out the panel and entrust it to one guy so it's easy to disown any responsibility. You think it's a coincidence each Floyd opponent gets ranked p4p? Canelo's 2nd best win is still a shot Mosley, worse than the guy graded F here by many posters as a Pac win.

Chuck's being doing the list like a year or so I believe.

I wouldn't say "each Floyd opponent get's ranked P4P". Everytime Mayweather's fought a P4P fighter they were already in there well before Mayweather was thought of as an opponent outside of Guererro.

And Canelo is in their for his ability more than anything and his last fight which seemed to legitimise his potential to most.

[djeffectz]

what kind of question is this, Pac can lose 3 more times by knockout and still leads in career achievements.