Comments Thread For: BoxingScene Update: Pound for Pound List and Review

[HeroBando]

I'd also like to note that while Dzinziruk was every bit decent ( I saw nothing in him literally) he was seen as someone that could give Martinez trouble, that was also a contributor. If Martinez didn't look so godawful against Murray I'd still have him Top 5, not anymore though.

Last time Dzin had fought a live body was 2.5 years ago, at sww as always. you're right that it was considered more dangerous at the time, but facts are his was a grossly inactive #9 sww moving up, looked shot ever since. that's not worth p4p points, if you're The MW Champ.

[bravestone]

Oh god you guys are so ******ed. Pacquaios last 3 opponents have all been on the P4P list, his ****ing loss to Bradley OBVIOUSLY isn't taken seriously in rankings because it was a blatant robbery, so besides that his legit loss came to Marquez, a fellow HIGHLY ranked P4P fighter. Losing to a P4P fighter doesn't make you get thrown off the list, especially when you are winning the fight up until the loss.

Use your damn brains and common sense, hes lost once recently, losing once doesn't throw you off the list unless its vs a BUM fighter who had no chance in the first place. Is Marquez a bum fighter? Didn't think so.

You expect Bradley and how **** he performed vs Pacquaio & Ruslan who pretty much demolished him to be on the P4P rankings? Rofl, cool story.

Funny you leave out the fact Pacquiao is 1-2 in his last 3.

Bradley beat Ruslan. Pacquiao was face first last time I saw him and is fighting a no hoper in his next fight.

Is he really P4P worthy to you? Can't have it both ways.

[HeroBando]

Funny you leave out the fact Pacquiao is 1-2 in his last 3.

Bradley beat Ruslan. Pacquiao was face first last time I saw him and is fighting a no hoper in his next fight.

Is he really P4P worthy to you? Can't have it both ways.

Dude the guys that run rankings are not usually petty fanboys like you. They know how they scored Pac Bradley, it's on paper:

http://boxrec.com/media/index.php/Ma...imothy_Bradley

[bravestone]

Dude the guys that run rankings are not usually petty fanboys like you. They know how they scored Pac Bradley, it's on paper:

http://boxrec.com/media/index.php/Ma...imothy_Bradley

How am I a petty fanboy? I scored it for Pacquiao as well you fcking numpty.

[HeroBando]

How am I a petty fanboy? I scored it for Pacquiao as well you fcking numpty.

That only proves it was a dominant Pac win, so you're a petty fanboy on ALL available evidence. so why would that demote him?

[bravestone]

That only proves it was a dominant Pac win, so you're a petty fanboy on ALL available evidence. so why would that demote him?

No, I just know how to score bouts.

He got schooled by Marquez who he tried to drag back up to welter then laid out by Marquez again. How many losses does a guy need to be out of the top 10?

[T18Z]

How am I a petty fanboy? I scored it for Pacquiao as well you fcking numpty.

Then you'd realize that Pacquaio is up 2 fights to 1 in his last three, and losing to Marquez, a top 5 P4P and future hall of famer doesn't drop him out of the P4P list.

Also, there's a difference between close fights (Marquez vs. Pacquaio) and one sided beat downs (Bradley), the former doesn't change your P4P ranking much. Stop suggesting that Pacquaios wins over Marquez were one sided, because it's bloody obvious they were all close, the scores say so, and the fans say so, so just shut up and face the fact 1 loss to Marquez doesn't throw Pacquaio off the list, just like if Marquez loses to Bradley I wouldn't expect him off the list either, just lower down.

[bravestone]

Then you'd realize that Pacquaio is up 2 fights to 1 in his last three, and losing to Marquez, a top 5 P4P and future hall of famer doesn't drop him out of the P4P list.

2 losses to a 40 year old should move Manny out of the top 10.

[T18Z]

2 losses to a 40 year old should move Manny out of the top 10.

You're a ******, age doesn't mean everything. Marquez is still a great fighter at his age, as is Floyd, and as is Manny. You are grasping for straws now, just stop lol. Age doesn't define fighters, they define themselves, don't be so narrow minded.

[bravestone]

You're a ******, age doesn't mean everything. Marquez is still a great fighter at his age, as is Floyd, and as is Manny. You are grasping for straws now, just stop lol. Age doesn't define fighters, they define themselves, don't be so narrow minded.

So how does Manny getting outboxed, then put to sleep help his cause?