Comments Thread For: BoxingScene Update: Pound for Pound List and Review

[Rapid Counter]

No, he's on the list for beating Bute and Kessler.

For those talking about inactivity Ward fought last September, that's only 9 months ago. Mayweather usually leaves 12 months between fights so time to stfu.

Still not good enough in my opinion to get in the top 5. Above Sergio who is giving away weight in every fight? Apart from his last fight which I feel Martinez lost he has dominated that division. Froch isn't even the best in his own division and only beat Kessler by 2 rounds, a guy he was expected to dominate.

Forget resume, that's not p4p, all things being equal Bradley would toy with Froch and he is nowhere to be seen. Anyway, it is what it is, just a guys opinion on something that can never really be proved. I don't know why I even posted in this thread lol

[Kagami Taiga]

He had a long way to fall, you know. This is not Segura, or even Donaire

Pac hasnt looked impressive in a long time. a long time.even besides the marquez ko, its clear hes slipped enough that hes not the elite fighter he was. great fighter. is he elite still? im not convinced.

[T18Z]

Seriously. Pac just got KTFO by a blown up lightweight.

Where is Bradley? The list makes no sense.

Oh god you guys are so ******ed. Pacquaios last 3 opponents have all been on the P4P list, his ****ing loss to Bradley OBVIOUSLY isn't taken seriously in rankings because it was a blatant robbery, so besides that his legit loss came to Marquez, a fellow HIGHLY ranked P4P fighter. Losing to a P4P fighter doesn't make you get thrown off the list, especially when you are winning the fight up until the loss.

Use your damn brains and common sense, hes lost once recently, losing once doesn't throw you off the list unless its vs a BUM fighter who had no chance in the first place. Is Marquez a bum fighter? Didn't think so.

You expect Bradley and how **** he performed vs Pacquaio & Ruslan who pretty much demolished him to be on the P4P rankings? Rofl, cool story.

[Doctor_Tenma]

For yall criticizing Rigo being over Mares and Froch, y'all do know P4P is not JUST about resume right? Rigo made the fighter of the year and top FIVE P4P look silly.

H2H would you pick Froch or Mares over Rigo? Who out there is more skilled than Rigo?


Posted from Boxingscene.com App for Android

Head to head I wouldn't have picked Mares over Moreno and we all saw how that turned out. Fights aren't won on paper, and Mares has already beaten Agbeko, Darchinyan, Moreno, PDL and Perez (IMO) where as Rigondeaux beat Donaire. There is really no justifying it, Mares has put in far more work.

Cause he has a much better top level win. That's what launched Sergio into the top 5. Beat the guy and took his place. Not saying it has to work that way, but that would be a justification

What launched Martinez into the Top 5 was a multitude of wins that stemmed from knocking out Paul Williams.

[HeroBando]

Pac hasnt looked impressive in a long time. a long time.even besides the marquez ko, its clear hes slipped enough that hes not the elite fighter he was. great fighter. is he elite still? im not convinced.

He had a close fight vs p4p JMM, his ******nite. Many had him losing, but a press row majority did not, including Cliff and Jake who both had Pac winning. Then easily gave p4p Bradley his first loss, in everyone's eyes. Finally, looked better than ever vs JMM before being KTFOed. Who in the sport has fought 3 legit (so forget Canelo, Guerrero) p4pers in a row? Hell Ward has one top 10 opponent careerwise.

[.:: JSFD26 ::.]

Quote:

Originally Posted by .:: JSFD26 ::.

For yall criticizing Rigo being over Mares and Froch, y'all do know P4P is not JUST about resume right? Rigo made the fighter of the year and top FIVE P4P look silly.

H2H would you pick Froch or Mares over Rigo? Who out there is more skilled than Rigo?


Posted from Boxingscene.com App for Android

Head to head I wouldn't have picked Mares over Moreno and we all saw how that turned out. Fights aren't won on paper, and Mares has already beaten Agbeko, Darchinyan, Moreno, PDL and Perez (IMO) where as Rigondeaux beat Donaire. There is really no justifying it, Mares has put in far more work.

Quote:

Originally Posted by HeroBando

Cause he has a much better top level win. That's what launched Sergio into the top 5. Beat the guy and took his place. Not saying it has to work that way, but that would be a justification

What launched Martinez into the Top 5 was a multitude of wins that stemmed from knocking out Paul Williams.

Umm how can you compare Moreno to Rigo? He doesn't have Rigo's power, speed or footwork... I was one of the few who picked Mares over Moreno so I guess I can only speak for myself.


Posted from Boxingscene.com App for Android

[Doctor_Tenma]

Umm how can you compare Moreno to Rigo? He doesn't have Rigo's power, speed or footwork... I was one of the few who picked Mares over Moreno so I guess I can only speak for myself.


Posted from Boxingscene.com App for Android

Your not understanding me, and no I'm not comparing the two. I'm strictly saying that whether you feel Rigondeaux may slice through Mares, fights are fought on paper, which is why resume is important when factoring P4P.

[Chris Collins]

Still not good enough in my opinion to get in the top 5. Above Sergio who is giving away weight in every fight? Apart from his last fight which I feel Martinez lost he has dominated that division. Froch isn't even the best in his own division and only beat Kessler by 2 rounds, a guy he was expected to dominate.

Forget resume, that's not p4p, all things being equal Bradley would toy with Froch and he is nowhere to be seen. Anyway, it is what it is, just a guys opinion on something that can never really be proved. I don't know why I even posted in this thread lol

Yet he went life and death with ruslan.

[SaldanaCC]

This list is rediculouse!!!!!!!!
I dont give a f**k whos fighting....until floyd loses he should always be on top period.
Alot of the fighters on this list should not be there or in the place they were put pacman should not be on this list sergio needs to be last if that just to name a couple wrongs.

[LaBéstia]

Ward has no business being on the top 5 much less be number 1! pathetic!!!