Comments Thread For: BoxingScene Update: Pound for Pound List and Review

[bravestone]

He was also winning the round, 2 seconds later he would be 2 points up. You can't comprehend the fact that Pacquaio looked impressive against Marquez, clearly. He showed that he was performing better against him than previously, but sadly got overconfident and it cost him the fight.

Diaz looked impressive against Marquez too. Both got KTFO though so I'm not sure the point you're trying to make.

[blak81]

Froch is not a top 10 P4P fighter. Ward should b #8 or #7. Where is Bradley?

Rigo should be #5 or #6.Mares should be #10.

Roman must have got a bump from Estrada W over Viloria. Still don't agree.

[Kagami Taiga]

I can't see how anyone can have Andre Ward at #1 when he hasn't done anything of any note since 2011.

Roman Gonzalez is one of the best up and coming fighters in the world but there is no way he has earnt a Top 10 P4P spot.

exact same thing i said.

[Ichee]

thats crazy. marquez just chinned the p4p top 2 fighter, but that doesnt even matter, just look at their skill set. marquez is a master, ward is a bit dirty really.

Quoted for truth, although I like Ward complex style, I have to give Marquez the edge when assessing their skillset. Marquez also shown while mixing it in wars to break down his opponents by out thinking them while under fire.

My top 3 will look like this on the P4P list based off intellect, skill, and the ability to never fold.

1.) Floyd Mayweather
2.) Juan Manuel Marquez
3.) Andre Ward

[Kagami Taiga]

He had a close fight vs p4p JMM, his ******nite. Many had him losing, but a press row majority did not, including Cliff and Jake who both had Pac winning. Then easily gave p4p Bradley his first loss, in everyone's eyes. Finally, looked better than ever vs JMM before being KTFOed. Who in the sport has fought 3 legit (so forget Canelo, Guerrero) p4pers in a row? Hell Ward has one top 10 opponent careerwise.

idc if its his kryptonite or not. and what 3 legit p4pers are we talking?? stop it. if you are a pac fan, great. but he just got koed. any fighter that gets koed the way he did doesnt belong on a p4p list. its just not warranted. esp when they have looked less than impressive for the better half of 2 yrs. nothing against pac but he shouldnt be on the list where we have fighters dominating and winning who deserve it more.

[HeroBando]

idc if its his kryptonite or not. and what 3 legit p4pers are we talking?? stop it. if you are a pac fan, great. but he just got koed. any fighter that gets koed the way he did doesnt belong on a p4p list. its just not warranted. esp when they have looked less than impressive for the better half of 2 yrs. nothing against pac but he shouldnt be on the list where we have fighters dominating and winning who deserve it more.

3 fights in a row against legit p4pers, jmm > bradley > jmm.

Let me get this right, if Floyd looks good and gets KOed clean, he's out of the top 10?

[bravestone]

3 fights in a row against legit p4pers, jmm > bradley > jmm.

Let me get this right, if Floyd looks good and gets KOed clean, he's out of the top 10?

So why isn't Bradley top at least? You can't say "Pac lost to P4P
ers" then try and exclude Bradley,

[Kagami Taiga]

3 fights in a row against legit p4pers, jmm > bradley > jmm.

Let me get this right, if Floyd looks good and gets KOed clean, he's out of the top 10?

i have no issue with that. if floyd gets koed by any fighter around his weight class rite now, hes essentially done. because frankly, none of them are elite, well besides jmm. and even that wouldnt be the same situation because floyd has looked relatively great lately in comparison to how manny looked.

[HeroBando]

i have no issue with that. if floyd gets koed by any fighter around his weight class rite now, hes essentially done. because frankly, none of them are elite, well besides jmm. and even that wouldnt be the same situation because floyd has looked relatively great lately in comparison to how manny looked.

Alright, hope I get to hold you to that

[bravestone]

3 fights in a row against legit p4pers, jmm > bradley > jmm.

Let me get this right, if Floyd looks good and gets KOed clean, he's out of the top 10?

Why wouldn't he be? Where was Roy JOnes on the P4P list when got sparked out by Tarver