Comments Thread For: BoxingScene Update: Pound for Pound List and Review

[Weebler I]

Froch is 5th on the list for for beating Kessler? A guy that he was supposed to beat? So if Kessler beat Froch would Kessler be top 10 p4p? I don't think so. I can understand pushing Rigo up there, he did dominate a legit p4p fighter and was giving away weight come fight night too.

No, he's on the list for beating Bute and Kessler.

For those talking about inactivity Ward fought last September, that's only 9 months ago. Mayweather usually leaves 12 months between fights so time to stfu.

[Oasis_Lad]

Brilliant list! I wish this list was biological and shaped like a penis so I could suck it dry.

[bravestone]

Rigo over Froch and Mares?!?...gtfoh!!!...no love for Donaire and Bradley but Pac got iced and hasn't officially won a fight since 2011....Ward is the king, he's driving the throne and Floyd is riding ******* with Marquez chilling out in the back sippin' on that gold water ....Rigo is cool and his skills makes him worth mentioning but his body of work is not that deep....I love how Rigo schooled Donaire but it wasn't worth a top 5 spot on the p4p list...c'mon now!!

Awesome huh ......

[HeroBando]

How is Rigondeaux above Froch and Mares, when those two have put in more work? Lets be realistic here.



Not even......

Cause he has a much better top level win. That's what launched Sergio into the top 5. Beat the guy and took his place. Not saying it has to work that way, but that would be a justification

[ИATAS]

How is Rigondeaux above Froch and Mares, when those two have put in more work? Lets be realistic here.



Not even......

Easy. Rigondeaux has a better victory on his resume than anyone Froch or Mares beat. And not only did he beat a #5 pound 4 pound fighter and 2012's fighter of the year, he made him look foolish.

[.:: JSFD26 ::.]

For yall criticizing Rigo being over Mares and Froch, y'all do know P4P is not JUST about resume right? Rigo made the fighter of the year and top FIVE P4P look silly.

H2H would you pick Froch or Mares over Rigo? Who out there is more skilled than Rigo?


Posted from Boxingscene.com App for Android

[HeroBando]

WAIT, so Pacquiao is still top 10, but Nonito is off, I understand Nonito being off, but no one in the boxing community can justify Pac on any top 10 PFP list.

This is surprising to you? Pac is in every p4p list I checked. I haven't checked fighthype, or Duckett's though.

[Kagami Taiga]

This is surprising to you? Pac is in every p4p list I checked. I haven't checked fighthype, or Duckett's though.

he really shouldnt be. so even if he is, its unwarranted.

[Jloro]

Sergio should still be above Rigo Froch and Mares

[HeroBando]

he really shouldnt be. so even if he is, its unwarranted.

He had a long way to fall, you know. This is not Segura, or even Donaire