Manny Pacquiao's resume hasn't improved since 2009 !!

[John Barron]

well, since he's been named boxer of the decade and awarded numerous other accolades, its safe to say a number of boxing experts and scribes do not share your opinion.

william hung of boxing.

[Chopper417]

well, since he's been named boxer of the decade and awarded numerous other accolades, its safe to say a number of boxing experts and scribes do not share your opinion.

His best wins are below 135, that simply is not up for debate.

[jrosales13]

Completely agree, what a complete joke. Take away the Margs win against Cotto, when was the last time either Margarito or Clottey won a meaningful boxing match? Clottey beating Judah in 2008? Margarito beating Cintron in 2008?

How you going to take a mans win?

Take away Ortiz win against Berto, take away Mosley win against Margarito, take away Oscar win against Mayorga, take away away Baldomir win against Judah, take away Judah win against Spinks whens the last time they won a meaningful fight?

It's kind of ******ed to use that type of logic.

[jrosales13]

His best wins are below 135, that simply is not up for debate.

Well of course that's when he was fight at his more natural weight-classes with people his size. Same like Floyd Jr who's best wins are at 135 and below.

[jtiger777]

arum ruined pac

[jrosales13]

Wazaa is right.

Cotto good fight against a good fighter and a good win.

Then it got worse with Clottey. But, still OK. Because, of his great run in 08 and 09 that a Clottey fight seemed good.

But, then the opponents got worse and he followed it up with Margarito.

Then it got even worse and he followed that up with Mosley.

And, now it got even worse and his following that up with JMM at 144.

So yes since Cotto he hasn't improved his legacy.

[Nonitard]

Clottey, Margarito and Mosley are lousy opponents, but insert someone else in there and it wouldnt be any better either.

Sorry, but fighting Andre Berto or Victor Ortiz during that time span is not gonna do much for his legacy either. Mayweather just beat Ortiz, is anyone saying Floyd's legacy got better since De La Hoya? It has remained the same.

Berto is unskilled and a bum. It only sounds like a sexy name because he was undefeated at one point and has power and is young.

Pac's legacy is intact, he was Fighter of the Decade and only has Mayweather to fight.

[Come∂ian]

How you going to take a mans win?

Take away Ortiz win against Berto, take away Mosley win against Margarito, take away Oscar win against Mayorga, take away away Baldomir win against Judah, take away Judah win against Spinks whens the last time they won a meaningful fight?

It's kind of ******ed to use that type of logic.

hahahahaha

[AFighter4U]

Explain in detail why you think this...
Other than the guys being "Bigger" than him, none of the guys he faced had anything left.

Clottey: He basically admitted in pre-fight interviews & post fight interviews that he was "Supposed to lose", plus he just lost the fight before (Bob fixed that fight) plus Clottey was not allowed to re-hydrate to much.

which pre-fight interview pray tell, did clottey say he was supposed to lose?
he lost his last fight against Cotto in a CLOSE FIGHT. and rumors of him not being allowed to rehydrate to much are just that.. rumors. no respectable news outlet ran that story.

Marg: It was all down hill after Shane Oldsley spanked him and tomatoe can Garcia took him all 12 rounds.
Plus forcing him to come in at 150? Dead man walking.

dead man walking? MOST of Margarito's fights were at 147 dude. and you say at 150 he's dead man walking? meh.

Shane: 40! lost his last 2 fights? Nothing more to say here.

crap fight. no argument from me there.

JMM: I love JMM but really? he's almost 40 now, plus Floyd has already proved he can't hold the weight above 135.

yeah. and that's why floyd decided to cheat with his weight just to be sure that he wins against a smaller, older foe in spite of having ALL the advantages in his favor.

[Chopper417]

How you going to take a mans win?

Take away Ortiz win against Berto, take away Mosley win against Margarito, take away Oscar win against Mayorga, take away away Baldomir win against Judah, take away Judah win against Spinks whens the last time they won a meaningful fight?

It's kind of ******ed to use that type of logic.

In light of what has happened with Margarito since I simply disagree, period. Everyone has their own opinion on Margs and the plaster but I simply do not view the Cotto win in the same light anymore, that is my opinion, and I think it is more than substantiated considering the man is a proven cheater. Think what u want.

Every fight u named above has not involved a proven cheater except for one (Margarito vs Mosley) so please don't for one minute try to act like they are even remotely similar situations.