Comments Thread For: Weighing 168 - BoxingScene’s Pound for Pound Top Ten

[Spray_resistant]

It's crap. It excludes an entire weight division.

Even though I have Wlad on mine because he is the most dominant boxer in the world today BS's is good for the standard BS is using but yeah there is no real rule that say p4p excludes HWs......in fact there is no p4p rules at all because its all just made up

[dorruel2.0]

Stop crying about Paul at 3. The kid has put in work. Eat ****.

Quintana whooped his ass, Martinez whooped his ass, and Cintron was whoopin his ass. Only 1 of those fighters are A class lol. Williams is clearly the most overrated fighter in boxing and most tend to agree.

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

I dont like Heavies on P4P Lists. The heavyweight division and all the fighters except one are **** anyway.

Vitali looked shot in his last fight. Wlad is good. But hs not one of the best 10 in the world.

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

Quintana whooped his ass, Martinez whooped his ass, and Cintron was whoopin his ass. Only 1 of those fighters are A class lol. Williams is clearly the most overrated fighter in boxing and most tend to agree.

I guess thats why MOST writers rank him at 3. With only Pac and Floyd rated higher.

[Spray_resistant]

I dont like Heavies on P4P Lists. The heavyweight division and all the fighters except one are **** anyway.

Vitali looked shot in his last fight. Wlad is good. But hs not one of the best 10 in the world.

Wlad is better overall than PWill p4p, if you scaled them both down in weight to about LHW slowing Paul down a bit and speeding Wlad up while Paul gets to have more pop and you take some away from Wlad.

I think Wlad ko's him because Paul's aggressive style would have him walking into a hard punching LHW Wlad's shots with his countering defensive style.

^^^^ scenarios like this are what p4p is based on.

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

Wlad is better overall than PWill p4p, if you scaled them both down in weight to about LHW slowing Paul down a bit and speeding Wlad up while Paul gets to have more pop and you take some away from Wlad.

I think Wlad ko's him because Paul's aggressive style would have him walking into a hard punching LHW Wlad's shots with his countering defensive style.

^^^^ scenarios like this are what p4p is based on.

Arthur Abraham would beat Paul Williams. Doesnt mean he should be in the P4P List.

[dorruel2.0]

I guess thats why MOST writers rank him at 3. With only Pac and Floyd rated higher.

idk about that. Last i checked the ring had him at 7, and most boxing fans i know and even users on this website think Williams is the most poverrated fighters since calzaghe. Its almost as if they save that #3 spot for the overrated hypejob

[Spray_resistant]

Arthur Abraham would beat Paul Williams. Doesnt mean he should be in the P4P List.

If you scaled them to the same size and you think AA wins it does.

Thats all p4p is, its not about wins at all it more about perceived skill and ability.

It just so happens that skilled fighters with ability win alot as crazy as that sounds and when one skilled fighter with ability gets another good win we have to re-evaluate how skilled and able he is thus bumping him up on your majical list.

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

idk about that. Last i checked the ring had him at 7, and most boxing fans i know and even users on this website think Williams is the most poverrated fighters since calzaghe. Its almost as if they save that #3 spot for the overrated hypejob

Well there is nothing that can be done about it. Time to buy a bridge and get over it.

[dorruel2.0]

Wlad is better overall than PWill p4p, if you scaled them both down in weight to about LHW slowing Paul down a bit and speeding Wlad up while Paul gets to have more pop and you take some away from Wlad.

I think Wlad ko's him because Paul's aggressive style would have him walking into a hard punching LHW Wlad's shots with his countering defensive style.

^^^^ scenarios like this are what p4p is based on.

Hell yeah, but heavies shouldnt be on this list