Comments Thread For: Weighing 168 - BoxingScene’s Pound for Pound Top Ten

[Spray_resistant]

Its one of the better P4P lists in boxing, of course I would change a few things like PWill being so highly rated though could see how he is as he has several very good wins.

Good job BS.

[qwerty07]

I don't think a fighter should lose their number 1 p4p ranking until they are beaten, and since Manny has gotten the #1 ranking, he has never lost. And saying that Pac and May's resume aren't far apart....gotta disagree with a lot. A lot of people would disagree with that.

[check hook]

I just can't see anyway how P-Will can be over Dawson. I try to figure a way but can't see it...

Better resume-Dawson

P4P better skills overall=Dawson

That's where this his flops IMO....apart from that it's really quite good.

[Walt Liquor]

Excluding Heavyweight makes this list completely invalid. Especially hw's that have moved up divisions (the definition of PFP).

The list sucks until that is rectified in my opinion.

[Walt Liquor]

Its one of the better P4P lists in boxing, of course I would change a few things like PWill being so highly rated though could see how he is as he has several very good wins.

Good job BS.

It's crap. It excludes an entire weight division.

[throbk1974]

This doesn't look like a list of top 10 pfp fighters!!! It's a list of the writer's favorites!!

[GloriousG]

Calderon and Montiel are past their primes and should not be in the top ten. I know Montiel just beat Hassegawa but who has Hassegawa fought anyway? And Calderon was actually knocked down against tomato can iribe.


Here is my top ten: 1. Manny Pacquiao 2. Floyd Mayweather 3. Paul Williams 4. Chad "boring as hell" Dawson 5. Sergio Martinez 6. Andre Ward 7. Timothy Bradley 8. Celestino Cabellero 9. Miguel Cotto 10. Shane Mosley

[Walt Liquor]

calderon and montiel are past their primes and should not be in the top ten. I know montiel just beat hassegawa but who has hassegawa fought anyway? And calderon was actually knocked down against tomato can iribe.


Here is my top ten: 1. Manny pacquiao 2. Floyd mayweather 3. Paul williams 4. Chad "boring as hell" dawson 5. Sergio martinez 6. Andre ward 7. Timothy bradley 8. Celestino cabellero 9. Miguel cotto 10. Shane mosley

lol!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[dorruel2.0]

Williams at #3 is laughable.
no wonder this sports going to ****.

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

Stop crying about Paul at 3. The kid has put in work. Eat ****.