who beat the better version of hatton??floyd or manny

[The Big Dunn]

Can we reword the original post this way? Who would you rather fight, undefeated Hatton at 147 or the 1 loss Hatton at 140?

I'd rather fight the 1 loss Hatton only because he looked HORRIBLE in the tune up before the Manny fight.

[letsgobrady]

Either none of you who picked against Floyd knows anything about boxing or you are biased as hell!!!

Take your pick!!!



Hatton fought only once at 147 prior to Floyd and he looked sluggish and didn't look good. So after that poor performance what did he do? Did he go on to pummel guys at 147? No he went back DOWN to 140 and continued fighting as he probably realized 147 is not right for him. Naturally, when you get the call to fight someone like Floyd, Hatton jumped on it. Unfortunately it was at 147 where Hatton did NOTHING SPECIAL at that weight. What were you all expecting to happen when he faced Floyd?

Hatton lived at 140. Hatton had NEVER lost at 140. Before the Pac fight Hatton even said that at 147 he could lose but not at 140 as that was his territory.

Just look at his record before picking your biased pick!

didn't hatton call floyd out?
who were these fighters at 140 that are as good as the 147 fighters?it wasn't the weight it was the fighters
when cotto floyd and ricky were at 140 why didn't ricky fight cotto or floyd?
it wasn't the weight it was the competition

[COVID-19]

Floyd beat Hatton first, he was used toilet paper after that........

[M.I Truth ?]

Either none of you who picked against Floyd knows anything about boxing or you are biased as hell!!!

Take your pick!!!



Hatton fought only once at 147 prior to Floyd and he looked sluggish and didn't look good. So after that poor performance what did he do? Did he go on to pummel guys at 147? No he went back DOWN to 140 and continued fighting as he probably realized 147 is not right for him. Naturally, when you get the call to fight someone like Floyd, Hatton jumped on it. Unfortunately it was at 147 where Hatton did NOTHING SPECIAL at that weight. What were you all expecting to happen when he faced Floyd?

Hatton lived at 140. Hatton had NEVER lost at 140. Before the Pac fight Hatton even said that at 147 he could lose but not at 140 as that was his territory.

Just look at his record before picking your biased pick!

Idiot............ Read what I said. I said Pac KOs Hatton sooner than Floyd under any circumstance. How is that being biased against Pac? I also pointed out Hatton steps into the ring about the same weight at both 140 or 147. The only difference was that Hatton had been broken down and stopped already before he fought pac. AGAIN WITH THAT SAID Pac would still have stopped the Hatton Floyd fought in under 10 rns.

[ADP02]

didn't hatton call floyd out?
who were these fighters at 140 that are as good as the 147 fighters?it wasn't the weight it was the fighters
when cotto floyd and ricky were at 140 why didn't ricky fight cotto or floyd?
it wasn't the weight it was the competition

I know who called who out. That was nowhere near the point that I was trying to make!!!

Hatton, who is what, 5'6" and more importantly, did not look so good at 147 in his only fight there. So Hatton then went back DOWN to 140. Why did he go down instead of stay at 147?

Instead at 140 he won his titles and defended it there. Who? Well, guys like Kostya Tszyu.

Either way, Hatton was a premier fighter at the 140 weight division not at 147. The reason Floyd fought Hatton wasn't because he looked impressive at 147. It was because of his records that was established at 140.

This question should not even have been asked because it's so so obvious if you know enough about boxing or are not biased. I can't believe how many people fall for these dumb traps.

[ADP02]

Idiot............ Read what I said. I said Pac KOs Hatton sooner than Floyd under any circumstance. How is that being biased against Pac? I also pointed out Hatton steps into the ring about the same weight at both 140 or 147. The only difference was that Hatton had been broken down and stopped already before he fought pac. AGAIN WITH THAT SAID Pac would still have stopped the Hatton Floyd fought in under 10 rns.

Sorry bud, I clicked the wrong REPLY button.... I don't even remember reading your post .... my bad

I had read a few comments then looked at the poll and said this is crazy talk. How can people think Hatton fighting a premier 147 Floyd was the better man when he NEVER proved to be a 147lbs fighter......

If you ask any true unbiased boxing analyst they would say that Manny fought the real Hatton.

[letsgobrady]

I know who called who out. That was nowhere near the point that I was trying to make!!!

Hatton, who is what, 5'6" and more importantly, did not look so good at 147 in his only fight there. So Hatton then went back DOWN to 140. Why did he go down instead of stay at 147?

Instead at 140 he won his titles and defended it there. Who? Well, guys like Kostya Tszyu.

Either way, Hatton was a premier fighter at the 140 weight division not at 147. The reason Floyd fought Hatton wasn't because he looked impressive at 147. It was because of his records that was established at 140.

This question should not even have been asked because it's so so obvious if you know enough about boxing or are not biased. I can't believe how many people fall for these dumb traps.

who were these fighters that hatton beat at 140 besieds tszyu and the tell me which 1 of those fighters u think is better than the top 147 fighters at the time?

who has ricky fought at 140 that is better than collazo? ricky looked bad because who he fought not where he fought.ricky didn't look to good against lazcaono and that fight happened at 140 so what was the reason for that

[Chups]

Hatton undefeated at 140, struggled against Colazo in 147.

[letsgobrady]

Sorry bud, I clicked the wrong REPLY button.... I don't even remember reading your post .... my bad

I had read a few comments then looked at the poll and said this is crazy talk. How can people think Hatton fighting a premier 147 Floyd was the better man when he NEVER proved to be a 147lbs fighter......

If you ask any true unbiased boxing analyst they would say that Manny fought the real Hatton.

the hatton that wasn't as agressive as he usually is and had trouble with his trainer in training camp is the better hatton?

[ADP02]

who were these fighters that hatton beat at 140 besieds tszyu and the tell me which 1 of those fighters u think is better than the top 147 fighters at the time?

who has ricky fought at 140 that is better than collazo? ricky looked bad because who he fought not where he fought.ricky didn't look to good against lazcaono and that fight happened at 140 so what was the reason for that

"besides tszyu?"

He proved himself at 140. He fought ONLY at 140. He won titles ONLY at 140. He defended ONLY at 140 .... Hatton NEVER had proved himself at 147. This is too easy that you don't even need to know about boxing but ......