who beat the better version of hatton??floyd or manny

[immortal tech]

for those of you that say Hatton was overweight and had no business at 147 you know Hatton walking around weight is 195 right?

[Castor_Troy]

Alot of people kicked and screamed for the Hatton fight. And when it came off, I don't remember many people complaining about Ricky Fatton having to come UP to fight the top fighter in the sport AT THAT TIME. Some people thought Ricky would knock Floyd out. Then, Floyd knocks out Hatton, then they cry about Hatton having to come up 7 pounds. SMH.

They want it to happen so bad. The british forum went nuts when this fight was announced.


Reasons for fight to happen >>> What weight to fight.


again not anybody's fault but it happened at 147

[V.WEBB]

All those are considered and i agree that it's not Floyd's fault it happened at 140.

But we cant deny the reality that almost all of Hattons arsenal are nullified at 147 because clearly he's not even a big Jr Welterweight to begin with.


My point is. its not a foregone conclusion that Floyd's version is the better hatton version because he beat him first. Its very clear that Hatton is so much dangerous at 140.

What was all in Hatton's arsenal at 140 that wasn't there at 147?

[Aut_72]

Active *******s in the site: 35.5%

[Castor_Troy]

for those of you that say Hatton was overweight and had no business at 147 you know Hatton walking around weight is 195 right?

Yes we know he is fat.

and 140 is his optimum division.

what's your point?

[V.WEBB]

for those of you that say Hatton was overweight and had no business at 147 you know Hatton walking around weight is 195 right?

Right. That is why I called him Ricky Fatton in an earlier post.

They want it to happen so bad. The british forum went nuts when this fight was announced.


Reasons for fight to happen >>> What weight to fight.


again not anybody's fault but it happened at 147

But people are complaining about the weight right NOW (Pac supports mainly) and using THAT to say that Manny beat the better version. This isn't knew, its been going on.

[Castor_Troy]

What was all in Hatton's arsenal at 140 that wasn't there at 147?

-He's stronger on the inside at 140 w/c is critical in his style

-His power decreases at 147

[SouthpawStance]

Not even close...Floyd beat a better version of Hatton

Floyd beat a better version of Hatton. Regardless if you like Floyd or not, its true. To say PacMan beat a better version is just hattin.

[whirlwind]

pacquiao fought the shell...just like he did with de la hoya and cotto.

So by your logic Pac also is a shell of himself now because he already lost to Torrecampo, Singsurat and Morales right?

[Castor_Troy]

Right. That is why I called him Ricky Fatton in an earlier post.



But people are complaining about the weight right NOW (Pac supports mainly) and using THAT to say that Manny beat the better version. This isn't knew, its been going on.

lol we're not complaining its just too obvious that Ricky Fatton's OPTIMUM fighting division is Junior Welterweight. That is all. lol