If Floyd beats Shane, will you consider him #1 P4P?

[Hannibal Barca]

rating floyd over manny cause of a win against fat jmm and old shane isn't calling a spade for a spade.

its fanboyism.

And keeping Manny at #1, when he ducked both fighters featured in this bout, is flat out ******ed. Especially considering he's only #1 because Mayweather retired, he defeated two fighters Mayweather had already beaten, and followed that up with a win over a Cotto and Clottey.

You don't know **** about boxing.

[Boy Mayweather]

He already is P4P #1.

[Hannibal Barca]

A prime Barrera got KTFO by Junior Jones and lost the immediate rematch as well.

Anyone who thinks Barrera is better than Mosley is ******ed, simple.

These dudes don't know **** about boxing. Most of em have only been fans since 08.

[Ryannn]

And keeping Manny at #1, when he ducked both fighters featured in this bout, is flat out ******ed. Especially considering he's only #1 because Mayweather retired, he defeated two fighters Mayweather had already beaten, and followed that up with a win over a Cotto and Clottey.

You don't know **** about boxing.

no respectable boxing analyst should rate floyd over manny based on a win against shane.

floyd gotta beat pac to take the spot. plain and simple

[whirlwind]

Some Floyd fans are delusional. He faked retired for almost two years to avoid Mosley, Cotto and Margarito and did nothing to contribute in boxing when he retired. Then suddenly if he beats the 38 years old Mosley who got beat by Cotto who destroyed by Pac he will become #p4p1?

[Gutz]

no respectable boxing analyst should rate floyd over manny based on a win against shane.

floyd gotta beat pac to take the spot. plain and simple

Truth right here..

[Hannibal Barca]

no respectable boxing analyst should rate floyd over manny based on a win against shane.

floyd gotta beat pac to take the spot. plain and simple

Only time will tell.

Pac never beat Mayweather, or anyone else who was close to being P4P#1 when he fought them. You don't have to beat the #1 to become #1. Ask Pac.

[M.I.C.]

Last I heard Pac has entered politics and is currently not actively involved in boxing right now therefore Floyd is P4P #1, as I recall Pac became #1 when Floyd left the sport so there u go.

[Gutz]

Last I heard Pac has entered politics and is currently not actively involved in boxing right now therefore Floyd is P4P #1, as I recall Pac became #1 when Floyd left the sport so there u go.

If pac doesnt fight in a Year..

Then I will agree with this.. But Pac just beat a top WW a couple of months ago..

[-GDS-]

Marg wasn't bothered emotionally. The only different between Shane's Marg and other Marg's is that Shane's Marg's didn't becoming increasingly more authoritive. As to why, we all know. And it really doesn't matter if Pac is ranked higher than May P4P or not. Wouldn't mean that he's a more skilled fighter, and it wouldn't mean he'd be favored against him. Pac could be ranked twenty P4P spaces above Floyd, but he'd still lose. Make of that what you want.