If Floyd beats Shane, will you consider him #1 P4P?

[Ryannn]

What did Pac do while Floyd was gone? PED use aside he beat an Oscar, who as Roach described, was shot, drained, and dehydrated. Floyd had already beaten a younger and better version of Oscar at 154.

He beat a Hatton that as Roach described, was ruined since being KO'd by Mayweather. Hatton had also been brutalized by Juan Lazcano 2 bouts earlier.

He beat Cotto, who as Roach described, was ruined goods. A fighter who hadn't been the same since being assaulted by Margarito.

He beat Clottey... Yeah, Clottey.

Mosely > That overhyped resume.

first roach was full of ****, now all he says is the truth

you people just got to accept that history is gonna remember packy the greater fighter of the two. even if floyd beats manny.

floyd's ******ed fanboys are the only ones who say otherwise.

[Hannibal Barca]

funny how barrera has been conveniently omitted from this list

and floyd didn't "ruin" hatton. that was a weak-ass ko.

Barrera was Pacs best win, and I give him full credit for that bout.

Because a poster who knows little about boxing knows better than a seasoned trainer right? Right.

[Gutz]

Currently. This thread isn't about who's ranked where now, it's about whether or not the winner of the Mosely vs. Mayweather bout should be considered p4p #1.

Next.

If Floyd does beat Mosley..

Pac will still be #1..


Next..

[Ryannn]

Barrera was Pacs best win, and I give him full credit for that bout.

Because a poster who knows little about boxing knows better than a seasoned trainer right? Right.

and yet you say that there is no one in manny's resume that is better than mosley.

well, there's barrera. so yeah.

[Hannibal Barca]

first roach was full of ****, now all he says is the truth

you people just got to accept that history is gonna remember packy the greater fighter of the two. even if floyd beats manny.

floyd's ******ed fanboys are the only ones who say otherwise.

Roach can be full of ****, but he know's boxing. More so than any poster on these boards. When he strays off and falls under the illusion that he has any sort of expertise in PED use is when I bull****, especially when what he says is blatantly wrong. With that said, I don't pretend to know more about boxing than the man.

In your world maybe, but I'm sure the real world may have a different outlook.

Floyd isn't my favorite fighter nor is he in my top 5. You don't have to be a Floyd fan to call a spade a spade.

[Hannibal Barca]

and yet you say that there is no one in manny's resume that is better than mosley.

well, there's barrera. so yeah.

Barrera's batter than Mosely based on what?

[Ryannn]

Roach can be full of ****, but he know's boxing. More so than any poster on these boards. When he strays off and falls under the illusion that he has any sort of expertise in PED use is when I bull****, especially when what he says is blatantly wrong. With that said, I don't pretend to know more about boxing than the man.

In your world maybe, but I'm sure the real world may have a different outlook.

Floyd isn't my favorite fighter nor is he in my top 5. You don't have to be a Floyd fan to call a spade a spade.

rating floyd over manny cause of a win against fat jmm and old shane isn't calling a spade for a spade.

its fanboyism.

[Bong Bong]

For decisioning an over-the-hill, out weighed Marquez and an old Mosley?

[PureBoxer]

Barrera's batter than Mosely based on what?

A prime Barrera got KTFO by Junior Jones and lost the immediate rematch as well.

Anyone who thinks Barrera is better than Mosley is ******ed, simple.

[tudedude]

pac still will be. If you're in the same weight class as the current active p4p king, the only way you win it is by taking it from the man himself. That's why the fight must be made.