If Floyd beats Shane, will you consider him #1 P4P?

[nujabes77]

Yes.

Him beating Mosley is better then any win Pac has.

beating a 38yo shane... yea sure

[minasyan]

There is no way Pac can lose the top spot if he keeps on winning

This fight will see who's the 2nd best pound for pound

[Pacquiao'd]

No..

Floyd still needs to beat Manny to get his top spot back..


Even with Mosley on the resume.. Pac resume is still better..

cant fight someone who ran from you and your opponent

[Hannibal Barca]

No..

Floyd still needs to beat Manny to get his top spot back..


Even with Mosley on the resume.. Pac resume is still better..

There's no one on Pacs resume who's better than Mosely. Period.

Not a shot as Morales coming of an L to Raheem.

Not a ruined Cotto coming off a brutal beating from Margarito.

Not punching bag Clottey.

Not drained and dehydrated Oscar who Floyd had already beaten.

Not a ruined Hatton who Floyd had already Ko'd.

Next.

[FloydTBE]

Floyd came back fought number 2, beat him, pac rejects fight to face mosley and mayweather, then mayweather beats mosley, yes floyd wil be #1

[Pacquiao'd]

Floyd came back fought number 2, beat him, pac rejects fight to face mosley and mayweather, then mayweather beats mosley, yes floyd wil be #1

truth be told

[Hannibal Barca]

Floyd came back fought number 2, beat him, pac rejects fight to face mosley and mayweather, then mayweather beats mosley, yes floyd wil be #1

Bingo. And he completely dominated the #2 p4p fighter, who was robbed in a decision against Pac the year prior.

[Dan...]

beating a 38yo shane... yea sure

This is the problem with NSB, there are just so many ******s on both sides of most arguments.

Who cares if he is 38 years old? Was a win over a 38 year old Hopkins not a great win? He is coming off a crushing victory over the guy everyone rated #1 at 147.

Educate yourself.

[Hannibal Barca]

This is the problem with NSB, there are just so many ******s on both sides of most arguments.

Who cares if he is 38 years old? Was a win over a 38 year old Hopkins not a great win? He is coming off a crushing victory over the guy everyone rated #1 at 147.

Educate yourself.

And the same 38 year old man who Roach described as being "too good" for Pac to fight.

[Ryannn]

rating floyd over manny based on wins against shane and jmm isn't just a weak argument. its plain wrong.

as somebody already might have said, what manny has done while floyd was "retired" is too impressive for floyd to take the number 1 spot, even if he beats the #1 welterweight.

manny was already ahead of floyd even before he fought oscar.