If Floyd beats Shane, will you consider him #1 P4P?

[ajohnz]

for all the people who currently have pacquiao atop the p4p list...which there is nothing wrong with at this point.

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

Yes.

Him beating Mosley is better then any win Pac has.

[Dan...]

No, even though I am a Floyd fan.

Manny's body of work over the past couple of years relative to Floyd's has just been too impressive for a win over Mosley to get Mayweather the #1 spot back IMO. As it stands, Floyd pretty much needs to beat Pacquiao to become p4p king again as I see it.

[Dirk Diggler UK]

Depends on his performance but I would think he'd need to beat Pacquiao. It'd kinda be like 1(a) and 1(b).

[Doctor_Tenma]

Nope.

He'd have to do more then that.

[ajohnz]

No, even though I am a Floyd fan.

Manny's body of work over the past couple of years relative to Floyd's has just been too impressive for a win over Mosley to get Mayweather the #1 spot back IMO. As it stands, Floyd pretty much needs to beat Pacquiao to become p4p king again as I see it.

valid argument. I see your point when comparing the last 25 months or so.

[M.I.C.]

In reality Floyd is and has always been P4P #1 since the demise of RJ

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

No, even though I am a Floyd fan.

Manny's body of work over the past couple of years relative to Floyd's has just been too impressive for a win over Mosley to get Mayweather the #1 spot back IMO. As it stands, Floyd pretty much needs to beat Pacquiao to become p4p king again as I see it.

Co sign!!!!!! Thread/

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

Co sign!!!!!! Thread/

Did Pac beat Floyd to take his spot?

[SirTomJones]

Floyd needs to get Manny to gain the top spot.