If Floyd beats Shane, will you consider him #1 P4P?

[etlux]

Yes.

Him beating Mosley is better then any win Pac has.

true this.

[Aut_72]

I would put him depending on the way he beats him, if he beats Mosley like he did to Oscar, he would still be #2 as much as I like Floyd

But people can't say Floyd's last 2 fights were BS cause he beat 2 hall of famers, 2 of the best of this era. Pacquiao just beat Clottey (Who has a -2 winning streak) And Cotto (Has a 2-2 record in his last 4 fights, and 1-3 in the eyes of many)

[infamous larryx]

naw he has to fight manny..

[Pacquiao'd]

Did Pac beat Floyd to take his spot?

hit the nail on the head

[Hannibal Barca]

I wont bother responding to the ridiculous arguments from Pac fans, but yes, he should be considered P4P#1. Why wouldn't he?

[hhs661]

Yes. Manny fights since his 2nd fight with JMM have all been opponents specifically favoring his style. I'd like Manny to beat someone like Berto, Collazo or meet Timothy Bradley at a catch-weight and win one of those before I consider him the number 1 p4p fighter.

[Gutz]

No..

Floyd still needs to beat Manny to get his top spot back..


Even with Mosley on the resume.. Pac resume is still better..

[Gutz]

naw he has to fight manny..

^^^^ More Floyd fans need to learn from this guy..

[SkillspayBills]

Depends on how he wins. It doesn't matter either way. It's all opinion in the end.

[PureBoxer]

Yes, Mayweather is the true p4p1, especially after beating Mosley. These two guys were both ducked by Pacquiao.