If Floyd beats Shane, will you consider him #1 P4P?

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

Yes.

Him beating Mosley is better then any win Pac has.

Pacquiao Beating Cotto, Clottey>>>>>>>>>>>>>Floyds entire WW run including Mosley!!!!

[M.I.C.]

Floyd needs to get Manny to gain the top spot.

I dont recall Manny beating Floyd to get the top spot, just his leftovers

[Ido]

No. That actually puts him back on the p4p list.

[Dan...]

Did Pac beat Floyd to take his spot?

I don't really see how that is relevant Burner.

Assuming Floyd gets it done against Shane, I just don't think you can give Floyd #1 based on recent activity. You are comparing several very good wins from Manny, moving up in weight and fighting bigger guys, to basically Shane and Marquez a couple of divisions north of where he has been a great fighter.

I'm not necessarily saying Floyd isn't the #1 fighter p4p, just that he shouldn't be rated there based on the fights that have gone down.

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

Did Pac beat Floyd to take his spot?

It doesnt workk that way fool, and you know it.

Pacquiao's body of work ****s on anything Floyd have done, let alone in the last 2 and a half year.


Get real

[daggum]

Yes.

Him beating Mosley is better then any win Pac has.

how so? manny beat the best 126 pound fighter in barrera. the best 130 pound fighter in marquez. the best 140 pounder in hatton and cotto who already beat mosley. floyd hasn't fought the best in a division since castillo and mosley is the 2nd best so close but no cigar. none of those guys were 38 either.

[Pacmang]

Yes.

Him beating Mosley is better then any win Pac has.

Manny's skill and resume outshine Mayweather and Mosley put together. And I'm looking forward to Manny fighting that bald headed pirate Paul Williams. If he thought the Martinez beating he got was bad wait until he fights Manny.

[daggum]

I dont recall Manny beating Floyd to get the top spot, just his leftovers

and the guys he ducked like cotto. not to mention beating people like hatton and marquez in the actual weight divisions they fight in. remember how floyd got to number 1 #p4p and you will laugh your ass off. beating arturo gatti.

[NesNY]

I think everyone would consider them both #1 p4p to the point where debate is useless.

it's 50-50 at that point....and the only way to gain the p4p title again is by fighting each other.

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

I don't really see how that is relevant Burner.

Assuming Floyd gets it done against Shane, I just don't think you can give Floyd #1 based on recent activity. You are comparing several very good wins from Manny, moving up in weight and fighting bigger guys, to basically Shane and Marquez a couple of divisions north of where he has been a great fighter.

I'm not necessarily saying Floyd isn't the #1 fighter p4p, just that he shouldn't be rated there based on the fights that have gone down.

It doesnt workk that way fool, and you know it.

Pacquiao's body of work ****s on anything Floyd have done, let alone in the last 2 and a half year.


Get real

Ey fellas. Im willing to bet points that The Ring will rank Floyd P4P Number 1 if he dominates Mosley.