Comments Thread For: Roach: Shane Mosley Has Trouble With Speed/Movement

[Rome-By-Ko]

[QUOTE=No Ceilings;7650194]Mayweather didnt start his career 2007 man. He was boxing 11 years before that.[/QU

That's why i'm asking you what make's him an atg and mosley not?Mosley was in with the better fighter's mosley won some and lost some but that's what happen's when you seek out fighter's on your skill level.If mosley had the same resume that mayweather has do you think he would have a lost?

[IMDAZED]

Thats my thing there is no way to tell. They have two completely different styles of defense and styles of fighting altogether. Only way I can think of is rating their defensive qualities as a whole and seeing what they are good at.

Yeah except one did it against better opposition.

[jrosales13]

Thats my thing there is no way to tell. They have two completely different styles of defense and styles of fighting altogether. Only way I can think of is rating their defensive qualities as a whole and seeing what they are good at.

OK Burner................ fair enough I guess...

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

Yeah except one did it against better opposition.

And like I told Jro. Thats not Floyds fault. That was a golden age in boxing.

When I actually think about it out of all the guys Floyd couldve fought Manny is the only one who will be an ATG at the signing of the contract. Thats shows how different the age is we in.

Nell was no joke though loved watching him make Oscar look like a fool. Prolly my favorite memory of him.

[Rome-By-Ko]

Are we going to have a debate or is it going to turn into this?

Come on you even have to laugh when you see baldy name there.Listen if you put on the glove's i respect you.But you and i know there are different skill level's in the fight game.With the only fighter he was in the ring with being on that same level was hoya.he won he get's full credit and he is a atg but for you to say he is atg and mosley is not well that just don't sound right bro.

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

[QUOTE=romebyko;7650215]

Mayweather didnt start his career 2007 man. He was boxing 11 years before that.[/QU

That's why i'm asking you what make's him an atg and mosley not?Mosley was in with the better fighter's mosley won some and lost some but that's what happen's when you seek out fighter's on your skill level.If mosley had the same resume that mayweather has do you think he would have a lost?

How can we gauge that? Mosley didnt start at 126. Mosley isnt an ATG in my book because he hasnt done enough. He beats Floyd or Manny he'll have a better case.

[IMDAZED]

And like I told Jro. Thats not Floyds fault. That was a golden age in boxing.

When I actually think about it out of all the guys Floyd couldve fought Manny is the only one who will be an ATG at the signing of the contract. Thats shows how different the age is we in.

Nell was no joke though loved watching him make Oscar look like a fool. Prolly my favorite memory of him.

I don't think the argument is whether it's his fault or not. The bottom line is that if one person did it against better opposition they are rightfully considered the better defensive fighter.

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

Come on you even have to laugh when you see baldy name there.Listen if you put on the glove's i respect you.But you and i know there are different skill level's in the fight game.With the only fighter he was in the ring with being on that same level was hoya.he won he get's full credit and he is a atg but for you to say he is atg and mosley is not well that just don't sound right bro.

Why do you think Mosleys an ATG? Im a Floyd fan to the 10th power. I could hype Shane as an ATG to make Floyd look better but I just cant. Hes not an ATG.

[IMDAZED]

Why do you think Mosleys an ATG? Im a Floyd fan to the 10th power. I could hype Shane as an ATG to make Floyd look better but I just cant. Hes not an ATG.

Personally I can't call either one an ATG but I'll definitely have a different take on May 2nd.

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

I don't think the argument is whether it's his fault or not. The bottom line is that if one person did it against better opposition they are rightfully considered the better defensive fighter.

Well I agree to disagree.