Comments Thread For: Roach: Shane Mosley Has Trouble With Speed/Movement

[jrosales13]

Personally I can't call either one an ATG but I'll definitely have a different take on May 2nd.

In your opinion if Shane wins he becomes an ATG?

[Dynamite Kid]

Yeah except one did it against better opposition.

Dont laught at me lol but are you really in Zamunda?

Its in Africa right, where Akeem is from? Lol

[IMDAZED]

In your opinion if Shane wins he becomes an ATG?

Absolutely.

[IMDAZED]

Dont laught at me lol but are you really in Zamunda?

Its in Africa right, where Akeem is from? Lol

LOL. It's a made-up country.

[Dynamite Kid]

LOL. It's a made-up country.

My bad LMAO

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

He beats Floyd or Manny hes around the 100-150 range with Calzaghe somewhere.

[drudolphreese]

People in here are gauging floyd greatness by his skills. Just because he is the most skilled fighter doesnt mean he is an ATG fighter. all time great fighters do more than just fight hand picked opponents and doesnt go against the real challenges. the fact that people argue over his greatness lets you know he didnt do all he should have. no one argues the greatness of sugar ray len. after retirement he came back and fought Marvin Hagler. Floyd comes back and fights a fighter two classes under his and make him move up. that's the difference between great fighters and great skills.

[Rome-By-Ko]

[QUOTE=No Ceilings;7650229]

How can we gauge that? Mosley didnt start at 126. Mosley isnt an ATG in my book because he hasnt done enough. He beats Floyd or Manny he'll have a better case.

Mosley did not start his career at 126.He started it at 135 what's your point?So you feel maywether has done enough?well that's your opinion and here's mine.The reason people are not giving money may num 1 defensive fighter atg.Why people are not giving him atg fighter and putting him high in the list.It's because the man has not been in the ring with anyone with a few exceptions like hoya that had will to match their skill.If we would have seen him in with forest spinks margacheato and cotto i would agree but we did not see that.So what has he done beat up guy's that the real boxing fans knew he would beat.I think floyd is a atg but on his skill not on what he has done and who he has fought.mosley has fought everyone he has fought more ww and jr mw and ruled the lightweight div sorry man mosley is a atg and a first rd hof.

[IMDAZED]

He beats Floyd or Manny hes around the 100-150 range with Calzaghe somewhere.

Maybe but then Floyd is in that range too if he wins, no?

[jrosales13]

Absolutely.

Sounds about right... I was thinking the same thing.