Who has defeated more fighters in their PRIME: Mayweather or Pacquiao?

[Doctor_Tenma]

Seriously, it's not even close. You have to be a real nuthugger to vote for Pac on this one.

That's Boxingscene. I even made a thread on my old account. I once said I'll never take a poll involving Pacquiao seriously, till this day I don't.

[Cash Cow]

Corrales was weight drained

Yeah he was so weight drained that he decided to fight at the same weight for almost 4 more years.

dude relax!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!....he was ONLY weight drained for the Mayweather fight...not before nor after

[dans]

BTW Samurai. Baldomir had not lost in 9 years when Floyd fought him. Your post back there was the most pathetic display I've seen from you. You're a good poster, and better than that.

[shogunn]

BTW Samurai. Baldomir had not lost in 9 years when Floyd fought him. Your post back there was the most pathetic display I've seen from you. You're a good poster, and better than that.

he also had 9 losses going in, and was coming off wins against a very shot shot Gatti (RIP), judah, and before that, miguel angel rodrgiuez and aguzum? But yet some how Barrera and Cotto were shot? talk about spin

[Doctor_Tenma]

he also had 9 losses going in, and was coming off wins against a very shot shot Gatti (RIP), judah, and before that, miguel angel rodrgiuez and aguzum? But yet some how Barrera and Cotto were shot? talk about spin

Cotto wasn't shot although he may have lost some of that punch resistance. Cotto was more a mental thing. MAB was still good and MAB wouldn't beat Pacquiao on his best day.

[Calilloyd]

dude relax!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!....he was ONLY weight drained for the Mayweather fight...not before nor after

LOL yeah I forgot that's the way it works around here.

[Calilloyd]

he also had 9 losses going in, and was coming off wins against a very shot shot Gatti (RIP), judah, and before that, miguel angel rodrgiuez and aguzum? But yet some how Barrera and Cotto were shot? talk about spin

Barrera was not shot but Cotto was definitely past his prime. Even Freddie Roach said that so you can accuse him of spin too.

[letsgobrady]

funny how floyd gets no credit for beating oscar and ricky yet manny gets praised for those 2 wins

[Doctor_Tenma]

funny how floyd gets no credit for beating oscar and ricky yet manny gets praised for those 2 wins

I give Mayweather more credit for beating Mitchell, then Pacquiao gets for beating Oscar. True story.

[shogunn]

Barrera was not shot but Cotto was definitely past his prime. Even Freddie Roach said that so you can accuse him of spin too.

Cotto is debatable, but even so, that Cotto in the ring is still deadlier than a JLC in his prime, angel manfredy in his prime, Corrales
(RIP) in his prime. Taht puts this prime talk as just a way to elevate floyds resume.

He doesnt have a Cotto, Barrera, or Morales on his resume, but he did beat a "primed" baldomir. Greatest P4P ever.