Who has defeated more fighters in their PRIME: Mayweather or Pacquiao?

[Cash Cow]

Floyd fans listen up! I simplify it for you.

Pacman
7 tiltles in 7 different weight divisions- First in boxing history!
4 lineal titles in 4 different weight divisions-First in boxing history!
Pro from 106 up to 147-First in boxing history!
Pac fought 4 legends -the likes of Barrera, JMM, Morales on their prime and Oscar (except him) against Floyd-old overweight JMM and way past his prime Oscar.

Floyd
? first in boxing history
? first in boxing history
? first in boxing history
? legends

...ok ok...the 7 titles is nice....

but you are counting the the OPBF flyweight title & WBC "International" super bantamweight titles as legitimate belts?....


so who has fought more fighters in their primes?......

and yo do you really believe Morales was in his PRIME when he fought Pac?....

[baracuda]

...ok ok...the 7 titles is nice....

but you are counting the the OPBF flyweight title & WBC "International" super bantamweight titles as legitimate belts?....


so who has fought more fighters in their primes?......

and yo do you really believe Morales was in his PRIME when he fought Pac?....

pac won the wbc belt(his 1st lineal) at flyweight and IBF super bantamweight title you dumbass.......you mofos resort to guessing when you dont know...

[hypodermical]

floyd probably beat more fighters in their prime, but one could argue that the opponents that pac defeated who arent so "prime" are overall still better p4p than the fighters that floyd beat.
and one could also argue that pac did not beat them in his prime, ie morales, pac was still young and his boxing skills werent as refined as now.

[ThePunchingBag]

The only good fighters that Floyd beat in their primes are Corrales and Castillo.

I had Castillo winning their first fight, but Boxrec tells a different story so I'll leave it at that.

[JoeyNumbers]

Do you decide whether a boxer was past his prime after Pac/Mayweather fought them? Because that makes a huge difference. For example:

DelaHoya looked like a dangerous fight for Pac, turned out to be easy. Castillo looked like an easy fight for May, turned out to be hard.
Yet, Castillo is considered a prime fighter for May and ODLH not for Pac... even though it was way more risky for Pac to fight Oscar than Floyd to fight Castillo before their fights.

[Kevin Jesus]

Watch Mayweather lose in this poll.

You were right.

90% of Boxingscene is full of Pinoys or Floyd haters so i am surprised he didn't lose by a wider margin.

[Kevin Jesus]

Floyd Mayweather's notable prime opponents: Corrales, Castillo, Chavez, Hatton, Judah(Questionable), Corley

Manny Pacquiao Notable: Barrera, Marquez?, Morales(questionable), Cotto?, Hatton

I was being extra nice by adding Hatton and Morales.

[MakeDamnSure]

Corrales was weight drained

Floyd lost to Castillo

Floyd fought a past his prime Gatti

Floyd fought an old Past His Prime 10 losses Baldomir.

Floyd fought a shot DLH

Floyd fought Hatton at 147 (Hatton had problems at that weight w/ Collazo)

Floyd fought battle bloated worn out Marquez at 146 (Floyd cheating the Weight)

Pac KO Morales even when Pac was not at his peak yet. You're a fool if that is the best Pac that fought and KO Barrera and Morales. Did you see Pac throwing the right hand and using his footwork at all angles when he fought Marquez, Barrera and Morales.. The Pacquiao right now would send these 3 back to Mars.

[Roger Mellie]

Manny beat better fighters and has a better resume without question,so the whole notion of "prime" is a moot point considering Manny had stronger opposition. That said,both are great fighters and both are in their prime,so whats gone before or who pissed for longer last year wont have any bearing on the outcome of this fight.

[hugh grant]

Pac has beat better fighters....period. Even if the fighters who Pac beat might have been past their prime, they are still better than the fighters PBF beat in their prime.
Castillo lost to Hatton for example so easily when he was slightly past it. Thats how bad PBFs best opponents were. And we know PBF only beat hatton because it was at 147 with home advantage and a bias ref. Who PBF had a good talk to before the fight telling the ref how dirty hatton was and not to let him hold too much. Asking the ref to protect him. Total whinger and cry baby.