Who has defeated more fighters in their PRIME: Mayweather or Pacquiao?

[Cash Cow]

I have had many discussions with boxing fans and read many threads on the internet about who has the better resume between Floyd Mayweather & Manny Pacquiao. Many people say that because of Pac's wins over Barrera & Morales that he should be considered to have the better resume. It seems as if people rate resumes by NAMES and not the physical shape that the opposing fighter was in at the time that the fight took place.

So my question to you boxing fans is who has more PRIME WINS on their resume throughout their career.........Mayweather or Pacquiao?

[Cash Cow]

oh BTW..please list the fighters whom you believe were in or close to their physical primes at the time when Mayweather or Pacquiao beat them

[boxing2106]

mayweather...floyd beat undefeated ricky hatton,baldomir,demarcus corley, and a better dela hoya then the one pac fought jose luis castillo, pac lost to morales thier first fight. i can say he beat david diaz in his prime lol..and marquez who even i thought marquez won but the knockdown made the difference.. mayweather by far more impressive..despite me having him in my avatar.. ppl just like pac cuz hes more exciting nd i dnt mind that i like hiim too..but most of pacs competition been over the hill guys

[Haterfree]

Easily Maywerather. Not only were Diego & Hatton undefeated they were both top ranked P4P at the time Floyd fought them. He also beat other in their prime champions like Angel Manfreddy & Judah. Haters try to pretend Oscar was so old but Oscar was only 4 years older than Floyd also at the time they fought.

[Cash Cow]

Easily Maywerather. Not only were Diego & Hatton undefeated they were both top ranked P4P at the time Floyd fought them. He also beat other in their prime champions like Angel Manfreddy & Judah. Haters try to pretend Oscar was so old but Oscar was only 4 years older than Floyd also at the time they fought.

I wonder why people say Manny has a better resume then? I dont get it..

so basically it doesnt matter if you beat washed up fighters as long as they are big/recognizable names?

[Doctor_Tenma]

Watch Mayweather lose in this poll.

[boxing2106]

I wonder why people say Manny has a better resume then? I dont get it..

so basically it doesnt matter if you beat washed up fighters as long as they are big/recognizable names?

thats cus he doesnt.. pac will get exposed come march 13th.

[boxing2106]

Watch Mayweather lose in this poll.

naah he gon def win this one

[boxing2106]

the idiots who voted for pac still havent made a single post lmaooooooo losers they kno the truth

[daggum]

ill condense this thread into a more understandable guide. everyone floyd fights is in his prime. everyone pac fights is not.