Whose resume is better, Floyd's or Oscar's

Collapse
Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Sin City
    la mala vida
    Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
    • Nov 2006
    • 27551
    • 1,757
    • 2,208
    • 47,596

    #41
    Originally posted by GooGoo
    Both Whitaker and Quartey should've won. Trinidad fight should've been a draw. He lost to Hopkins, Mosley Twice, Money Mayweather and got another gift against Felix Sturm. How in the hell this a better resume then Money Mayweather who is a 6 time champion and 5 different weight classes and is still undefeated.
    who has Mayweather beaten?
    point proven.

    by your standard Oscar is way past his prime and everyone else other then Hatton and a couple others isn't worth mentioning.

    Oscar's wins (in his prime) are better then Floyd's wins.

    A title dont mean **** when there is so many getting handed around today, its who you fought and who you beat.

    And De La Hoya won against Whittaker and Quartey, you just a hater that won't give him his credit.

    Comment

    • TheGreatA
      Undisputed Champion
      Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
      • Dec 2007
      • 14143
      • 633
      • 271
      • 21,863

      #42
      Originally posted by gavinz1970
      Because last time I checked, 9 time champ in 6 different weight classes > 6 time champ in 5. DLH has losses, true, but then again he fought better opposition.
      Roger Mayweather fought better competition than both.

      Comment

      • GooGoo
        Banned
        Gold Champion - 500-1,000 posts
        • May 2006
        • 778
        • 408
        • 265
        • 943

        #43
        Originally posted by gavinz1970
        Because last time I checked, 9 time champ in 6 different weight classes > 6 time champ in 5. DLH has losses, true, but then again he fought better opposition.
        Oscar is actually really a 3 weight class champion and Money Mayeather is 4.

        I don't count Flolyds win againt Oscar, also I don't count Oscar wins againts Sturm, Mayorga and Bredahl. Oscar lost 5 times too.

        Comment

        • GooGoo
          Banned
          Gold Champion - 500-1,000 posts
          • May 2006
          • 778
          • 408
          • 265
          • 943

          #44
          Originally posted by Sin City
          who has Mayweather beaten?
          point proven.

          by your standard Oscar is way past his prime and everyone else other then Hatton and a couple others isn't worth mentioning.

          Oscar's wins (in his prime) are better then Floyd's wins.

          A title dont mean **** when there is so many getting handed around today, its who you fought and who you beat.

          And De La Hoya won against Whittaker and Quartey, you just a hater that won't give him his credit.
          I stopped reading after this.

          Comment

          • Jim Jeffries
            rugged individualist
            Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
            • Oct 2007
            • 20740
            • 1,376
            • 2,868
            • 54,838

            #45
            Originally posted by TheManchine
            Roger Mayweather fought better competition than both.
            Is Roger a 6 or 9 time world champ in 5 or 6 different weight divisions?

            There now you don't have to repeat yourself another 10 times.

            Comment

            • TheGreatA
              Undisputed Champion
              Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
              • Dec 2007
              • 14143
              • 633
              • 271
              • 21,863

              #46
              Floyd is really a 3-division (SFW, LW, WW) champion because Corrales, Castillo and Baldomir were real champions.

              DLH is really a 3-division (LWW, WW, LMW) champion too, maybe 4-division if the unified LW title counts.

              In my opinion in order to be the champion you need to beat the best in the division not some hand-picked bum for a WBO vacant belt.

              Comment

              • TheGreatA
                Undisputed Champion
                Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
                • Dec 2007
                • 14143
                • 633
                • 271
                • 21,863

                #47
                Originally posted by gavinz1970
                Is Roger a 6 or 9 time world champ in 5 or 6 different weight divisions?

                There now you don't have to repeat yourself another 10 times.
                You missed the point. Fighting better competition doesn't mean you have a better resume, BEATING better competition means you have a better resume.

                Floyd Mayweather has consistently beaten better competition than DLH and has lost to none.

                Comment

                • Jim Jeffries
                  rugged individualist
                  Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
                  • Oct 2007
                  • 20740
                  • 1,376
                  • 2,868
                  • 54,838

                  #48
                  Originally posted by TheManchine
                  Floyd is really a 3-division (SFW, LW, WW) champion because Corrales, Castillo and Baldomir were real champions.

                  DLH is really a 3-division (LWW, WW, LMW) champion too, maybe 4-division if the unified LW title counts.

                  In my opinion in order to be the champion you need to beat the best in the division not some hand-picked bum for a WBO vacant belt.
                  So you think Baldomir, with one defence of his title, a blown up old Gatti, was the best at WW over Margarito, who had held his belt for 5 years, with 7 successful title defences?

                  Comment

                  • TheGreatA
                    Undisputed Champion
                    Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
                    • Dec 2007
                    • 14143
                    • 633
                    • 271
                    • 21,863

                    #49
                    Originally posted by gavinz1970
                    So you think Baldomir, with one defence of his title, a blown up old Gatti, was the best at WW over Margarito, who had held his belt for 5 years, with 7 successful title defences?
                    Baldomir beat Zab Judah, the number 1 and the real champion in the division.

                    You know how the linear title goes, Baldomir>Judah>Spinks>Mayorga>Forrest>Mosley.

                    Comment

                    • Haterfree
                      Undisputed Champion
                      Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                      • Dec 2007
                      • 2039
                      • 105
                      • 0
                      • 8,299

                      #50
                      Originally posted by gavinz1970
                      So a win over a 34 year old with one fight in over 2 1/2 years tipped the scales for you? Who, besides Oscar was a HOF opponent for Floyd again?

                      How old were Pernell & Chavez when they fought Oscar? Oscar was 4 years older than Floyd. I guess thats a big difference to you. If you dont consider Diego & Castillo HOF you are ******ed. There legendary battle by itself earned them a place in the HOF. I regret it but Gatti will also get that call 1 day & Hatton isnt too far behind.

                      Comment

                      Working...
                      TOP