Whose resume is better, Floyd's or Oscar's

[The Hammer]

Prime Oscar was a far better fighter than prime Mayweather is.

[Parody]

Prime Oscar was a far better fighter than prime Mayweather is.

Quote of the year.

[jabsRstiff]

Question:

Why hasn't Oscar fought Winky Wright ? Oscar has been campaigning at 154 since 2001. It's 2008, & everyone who is anyone in/around that weight class has fought Winky....while the guy many claim "ducks no one" never mentions him.
He hasn't fought the 154lb stalwart because he knows he'd lose, & has no interest in facing a good (Winky's better than good) left-hander.

[Jim Jeffries]

Quote of the year.

You don't think May's fight proved that? I mean if an old, inactive Oscar can fight Floyd to a split decision loss, imagine what a prime Oscar would have done to him.

[Boxins'Leet]

ATG Faced

Oscar
JCC x 2 Win-KO both times
Camacho Win-KO
Trinidad Lost-UD (I'd say he won)
Whitiker Win-UD
Mosely Lost- 2 UD (come on he won one)
Hopkins Lost - KO
Mayweather Lost- MD

Honorable mention: Lejia, Gonzales, Carr, G. Hernandez, Castillejo, Vargas

Mayweather
Maybe JLC? x2 Win - UD
Maybe Corrales? Win - TKO
Maybe Hatton? Win - TKO
Oscar Win-MD

Honorable mention:G.Hernandez, Manfredy, Augustus, C. Hernandez, Juda, Mitchell

I think Oscar by a MILE

[Parody]

You don't think May's fight proved that? I mean if an old, inactive Oscar can fight Floyd to a split decision loss, imagine what a prime Oscar would have done to him.

^^^ hilarious, did you read what he said? Mayweather's prime was in his lighter weights, he said prime oscar is a better fighter than prime mayweather.

If you seriously think he is, then I feel sorry for you, and ill cry for you.

Yeah having a smaller ring, fighting a guy at 154 lbs where he has been fighting for years, gloves and other disadvantages, still getting beating him 116-112.

Oscar in his prime could'nt beat Whitaker or Quartey lost to Trinidad and Mosley.

I'm waiting for you to say Oscar is a better fighter prime vs prime gavinz

[jabsRstiff]

ATG Faced

Oscar
JCC x 2 Win-KO both times
Camacho Win-KO
Trinidad Lost-UD (I'd say he won)
Whitiker Win-UD
Mosely Lost- 2 UD (come on he won one)
Hopkins Lost - KO
Mayweather Lost- MD

Honorable mention: Lejia, Gonzales, Carr, G. Hernandez, Castillejo, Vargas

Mayweather
Maybe JLC? x2 Win - UD
Maybe Corrales? Win - TKO
Maybe Hatton? Win - TKO
Oscar Win-MD

Honorable mention:G.Hernandez, Manfredy, Augustus, C. Hernandez, Juda, Mitchell

I think Oscar by a MILE

I didn't know Camacho was an all-time great. I certainly know his peak was not at 147, in '97. He never acheived greatness, because he was ruined by edwin Rosario in '86.

[Boxins'Leet]

I didn't know Camacho was an all-time great. I certainly know his peak was not at 147, in '97. He never acheived greatness, because he was ruined by edwin Rosario in '86.

I stand corrected then, but you have to admit Camacho definately had ATG tools. Very good boxer IMO.

[Thread Stealer]

camacho is far from an atg.

what a waste of amazing talent he turned out to be.

[Haterfree]

Prime Oscar was a far better fighter than prime Mayweather is.

A cool Oscar is better than a cool Floyd. A millionaire Oscar is better than a millionaire Floyd. A prime Oscar is better than a prime Floyd. A gay Oscar is better than a gay Floyd. Whats with all this add a title to their name BULL****? The fact is Floyd & Oscar settled this **** in the ring & Floyd won. Deal with it haters!