Whose resume is better, Floyd's or Oscar's

[Parody]

Baldomir beat Zab Judah, the number 1 and the real champion in the division.

You know how the linear title goes, Baldomir>Judah>Spinks>Mayorga>Forrest>Mosley.

There is no point wasting your time......

[nmuburner22]

There is no point wasting your time......

Yeah hes a boob..he said JLC wasnt prime when he fought Floyd because he had 50 fights..not realizing he sometimes fought 6 or 7 times a year early in his career...what a dumbass.

[Jim Jeffries]

How old were Pernell & Chavez when they fought Oscar? Oscar was 4 years older than Floyd. I guess thats a big difference to you. If you dont consider Diego & Castillo HOF you are ******ed. There legendary battle by itself earned them a place in the HOF. I regret it but Gatti will also get that call 1 day & Hatton isnt too far behind.

Pernell was 33, but he was 25-0-1 in his last 26 fights, and was an active fighter.

The inactivity of Oscar affected him more than his age. But clearly 30 is usually part of a fighter's prime, 34 usually is not. And if you look at Oscar in the first Mosley fight, for example, and compare him to the Oscar that fought Floyd, huge difference.

[Haterfree]

[QUOTE=Sin City;3007091]

Chavez was the same age Oscar was when he fought Mayweather...
So Mayweather shouldn't get credit for DLH?

Either you are a liar or you just dont know waht you are talking about. Chavez was 36 when he fought Oscar & Oscar had like a 10 year age advantage. Although it was still a solid victory by Oscar. Oscar was 34 when he fought Floyd & Oscar is only 4 years older than Floyd.

[Jim Jeffries]

Either you are a liar or you just dont know waht you are talking about. Chavez was 36 when he fought Oscar & Oscar had like a 10 year age advantage. Although it was still a solid victory by Oscar. Oscar was 34 when he fought Floyd & Oscar is only 4 years older than Floyd.

You do realize Oscar also fought Chavez 2 years earlier? And a 30 year old fighter is usually better than a 24 year old fighter.

[Haterfree]

Pernell was 33, but he was 25-0-1 in his last 26 fights, and was an active fighter.

The inactivity of Oscar affected him more than his age. But clearly 30 is usually part of a fighter's prime, 34 usually is not. And if you look at Oscar in the first Mosley fight, for example, and compare him to the Oscar that fought Floyd, huge difference.

Blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah. The fact stands that Oscar loss to Floyd & since they both have impressive resumes the edge goes to Floyd.

[Boxinguru]

Win, Lose or Draw Oscar has been in with the better oppostion!

[RAESAAD]

I'm genuinely suprised by the poll results.....maybe I'm a bit of an Oscar lover but I just don't see it.Oscar has been making 1 million plus since like his 12th pro fight and has fought damn near everyone and many were fighters that will be remembered for a long,long time.Oscar never shyed from a challenge and even tho he has lost some fights I think the list he provides has more ATG type fighters than floyds.

[Jim Jeffries]

The fact stands that Oscar loss to Floyd & since they both have impressive resumes the edge goes to Floyd.

Yet you picked Floyd by a lot?

[Haterfree]

Yet you picked Floyd by a lot?

I just picked something that said Floyd. I didnt really notice that ****. My bad.