Whose resume is better, Floyd's or Oscar's

[Haterfree]

Being that Oscar loss to Floyd & they both have defeated about the same amount of HOFs. I would have to give Floyd the edge.

[Parody]

?????????????????

Dont mind Sin City, he is the biggest Oscar fan you will find here. Not disrespecting you Sin, its nothing to be ashamed of.

[Sin City]

Do losses count?

including the losses Oscar has still had a better career.

john john molina
whittaker
jorge paez
Jesse James Leija
Genaro Hernandez
Rafael Ruelas
Julio Cesar Chavez
Hector Camacho
Ike Quartey
Ricardo Mayorga
Vargas

im sure im forgetting some..
but unlike Floyd, Oscar was never afraid to fight the top comp in his division.

[TheGreatA]

ricky gonna be like sylvester stallone

you know why dem ppl made rocky one, two, three, four, five and ****in six ? cos ppl believe in bull****.

but dis aint gona be like dat. the better man goin to win

Roger Mayweather has fought better competition than both.

[GooGoo]

Oscar lost most of his big fights, Floyd is still undefeated. This is a no brainer, easily Money Mayweather.

[Jim Jeffries]

Being that Oscar loss to Floyd & they both have defeated about the same amount of HOFs. I would have to give Floyd the edge.

So a win over a 34 year old with one fight in over 2 1/2 years tipped the scales for you? Who, besides Oscar was a HOF opponent for Floyd again?

[Mike_Dee]

If Oscar won at least 3 of his 5 losses, then Oscar's resume would have been better then Floyd's. But, Oscar lost all of his biggest challenges while Floyd won all of his and Floyd has a win over Oscar so I'd have to give it to Floyd.

[Parody]

including the losses Oscar has still had a better career.


Whittaker
Genaro Hernandez
Julio Cesar Chavez
Hector Camacho
Ike Quartey
Vargas

im sure im forgetting some..
but unlike Floyd, Oscar was never afraid to fight the top comp in his division.

I have removed the ones that were speaking the fanboy in you, the ones that are left were good wins but lets not forget most people thought oscar was given gifts against whitaker and quartey. so that leaves us with grandads in chavez and camacho, and a tito trinidad leftover.

[flat1985]

Oscar has imo

[jabsRstiff]

[QUOTE=Sin City;3007033]including the losses Oscar has still had a better career.

john john molina= best days were at 130, gave Oscar hell
whittaker= best days were at 135, gave Oscar hell.
jorge paez= overrated former 126lb, shot fighter
Jesse James Leija= undersized. Beat no 135lbers to earn shot
Genaro Hernandez= 130lb champ, had nose broken by Mosley prior
Rafael Ruelas= good, devastating win for Oscar
Julio Cesar Chavez= SHOT, & already cut before fight started
Hector Camacho= Totally shot. Equally destroyed by Chavez at 140, 5 years earlier
Ike Quartey= Rusty, timid fighter....almost KO'd by JL Lopez in last fight before facing Oscar. Did not have one single fight between (Oct' 97- Feb '99)
Ricardo Mayorga= Human punching bag...already obliterated & shattered by trinidad
Vargas= Shattered by Trinidad