Whose resume is better, Floyd's or Oscar's

[robjr]

Im goin with Floyd on this one.. Because I Honestly believe Oscar lost 3 fights he got the decision for.. against quartay, whitaker, and sturm. Truly feel he lost all these fights.

Floyds only gift decision came in his 1st fight against castillo..

So ill definetly give my vote to floyd on this one when I go by resume..

[Sin City]

Chavez had like 100 fights and was pretty much washed up. Oscar would've never stopped a prime Chavez.

and Oscar hand't been through Trinidad, Mosley, Vargas, Hopkins, Whittaker, Quartey, etc. at the time? 100 fights doesn't amount to much if your not fighting anyone worth a mention.

[Jim Jeffries]

LMAO at anyone who picked Floyd at all.......let alone by far.

C'mon man, Floyd's 6 titles in 5 weight divisions, over gems like a 33 year old Gatti, a 35 year old Baldomir (only one title defence against Gatti), Zab Judah coming off a loss to previously mentioned, a 34 year old DLH with one fight in over 2 1/2 years and 2 losses in his previous 4 fights >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Oscar with 9 titles in 6 weight divisions.

[GooGoo]

and Oscar hand't been through Trinidad, Mosley, Vargas, Hopkins, Whittaker, Quartey, etc. at the time? 100 fights doesn't amount to much if your not fighting anyone worth a mention.

You mean losses and gifts??

[Parody]

C'mon man, Floyd's 6 titles in 5 weight divisions, over gems like a 33 year old Gatti, a 35 year old Baldomir (only one title defence against Gatti), Zab Judah coming off a loss to previously mentioned, a 34 year old DLH with one fight in over 2 1/2 years and 2 losses in his previous 4 fights >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>. Oscar with 9 titles in 6 weight divisions.

What is with your new found obsession for Floyd? We all know you dont like him, never have and never will.

Judah coming off a loss to who? > Baldomir
Floyd beat both, both were undisputed champs. Now tell me who did Cotto face that was coming off 2 losses and a 15 month inactivity...hint....Z** J*d**.....any guesses?

[nmuburner22]

Oscar loses every big fight.

Floyd wins every big fight.

Simple.

[Jim Jeffries]

What is with your new found obsession for Floyd? We all know you dont like him, never have and never will.

Judah coming off a loss to who? > Baldomir
Floyd beat both, both were undisputed champs. Now tell me who did Cotto face that was coming off 2 losses and a 15 month inactivity...hint....Z** J*d**.....any guesses?

This thread is not about Cotto, neither Floyd or Oscar has faced him.

I was a big fan of Floyd's back in his days at 130 and 135.

[Sin City]

You mean losses and gifts??

whittaker fight was close and could have went either way.
and DLH floored Quartey a second time to take the fight.
Trinidad he was robbed and the majority of people will tell you that.

[GooGoo]

whittaker fight was close and could have went either way.
and DLH floored Quartey a second time to take the fight.
Trinidad he was robbed and the majority of people will tell you that.

Both Whitaker and Quartey should've won. Trinidad fight should've been a draw. He lost to Hopkins, Mosley Twice, Money Mayweather and got another gift against Felix Sturm. How in the hell this a better resume then Money Mayweather who is a 6 time champion and 5 different weight classes and is still undefeated.

[Jim Jeffries]

Both Whitaker and Quartey should've won. Trinidad fight should've been a draw. He lost to Hopkins, Mosley Twice, Money Mayweather and got another gift against Felix Sturm. How in the hell this a better resume then Money Mayweather who is a 6 time champion and 5 different weight classes and is still undefeated.

Because last time I checked, 9 time champ in 6 different weight classes > 6 time champ in 5. DLH has losses, true, but then again he fought better opposition.