You seem incapable of understanding simple points, you appear to be a bit simple so ill try and explain in simple points for you:
With hindsight it was a good stoppage
At the time it was a bad stoppage.
You dont appear to know what hindsight means.
Everyone involved the HBO team, brook's father and members of his camp, the fan's, were all bemused to why it was stopped and were questioning Ingle for several minutes after the fight was stopped, Kell himself turned with his arms out asking why to Ingle..he then pointed to kells eye.
But hey YOU claim it was not ' weird ' at all....right? apparently you knew better than bernard hopkins and kell and kell's own father, who at the time was shouting at Ingle to not stop the fight.
Ingle did not know it was a serious injury at the time... agreed?
If he knew the extent of the injury the fight would be stopped in the 2nd. agreed?
So we can conclude he stopped the fight because of the swelling. right?
Swelling is not enough for a fight to be stopped.
Especially considering Brook seemingly wanted to continue, (which is the most important fact) he was having success, it was not a one sided beat down and he had a share of the rounds on the scorecards.
Hopkins: ' do you feel the stoppage was warranted, could you of fought on'?
Brook: ' absolutely, with a fight of this magnitude, it should of carried on'
I have watched the fight 3 times now.
As people are re-writing the fight as some kind of terrible beat-down in the last 2 round's, i will briefly summarise:
4th round, is golovkin's, but not totally one sided, brook landed several flush hook's which caught golovkin's attention and he nod's in acknowledgement, when the bell sound's, between the two men GGG appears to be more gassed, he takes several huge deep breaths, Hopkins notices this and also makes the point that the steam has gone from his punches and he is landing 'arm punches' and appears tired.
5th round, Golovkin comes out and starts throwing alot of punches, but missing many
Brook is riding with most of the semi landed ones and the only flush shot landed is a jab which snaps brook's head back
Brook then motions to say ' is that all you got '? whilst smiling, he is using head movement and seemingly unhurt and moving well.
He paw's at his eye, Brook lands several jab's, clinches then throws another 6 punch combination.
This is 1 second before Ingle throws the towl in:
Golovkin land's a body shot, throw's 3 more shot's, one land's partially the rest miss.
*Ingle Throws the towl in*
Golovkin then throws several more shots, 1-2 connect out of around 10. during the peroid Ingle is waving the towl, all of which are irrelevant as ingle already want's to stop it.
Now we have already made the logical conclusion the Ingle does not know it's a serious injury
So concluding, Ingle stop's the fight based on what?
A) Brook wanted to continue, he already stated his should of been allowed especially considering the magnitude.
B) Brook was not badly hurt nor was he taking a sustained beating, he was throwing shortly prior to ingle waving the towl
C) Brook was doing better than we all expected, was not losing 5-0 on the card's and had golovkin's face looking more marked up than his own.
D) Golovkin was the more tired of the two, appeared to be arm punching and was missing alot of his shot's
This is what im basing the 'weird' stoppage on.....OK?
Im going on fact's, not opinions, maybe you should give it a try instead of writing an essay on totally irrelevant ****e about obama?
Brook himself let his corner in the 2nd he was struggling. Clearly his corner, like you said, decided to give him a chance. They likely already knew he was risking his eyesight, but knew there was a lot riding on this fight. Much like you said they should, they let the fight go on for 3 more rounds.
I don't know more than Hopkins, but he didn't and probably still doesn't know as much as Brooks team does. Likewise, a boxer is going to save face as much as he can. If Brook said "No, they were right to throw in the towel my eye was ****ed" his stock would go down. It's his job to be a fighter, and that's what he did.
Here's the 5th round and immediate aftermath: https://streamable.com/fdrw there's 10 seconds where Brook fights back, but none of his power shots connect. Immediately before and after this, Golovkin is going for the kill, and 30 of his punches, 12 of them power shots, connect. Brook only connects 6 jabs in that time. For most of that video, Brook is on the ropes and getting pummeled.
Once the towel is thrown, Brook puts his arms up, but he doesn't contest the decision, he doesn't immediately argue with Ingle or the ref, he walks back to centre and touches gloves with Golovkin. He knew it was time himself to give up.