Joe Calzaghe's 46-0 vs Floyd Mayweather's 50-0

[KidDinamita]

Easy.. Mayweather Jr.

Calzaghe didn't fight the same opposition Mayweather fought.

It would have been better if the thread was who is greater between Pacquiao and Mayweather

[DreamFighter]

Calzaghe better comparison is Sven Ottke.

[hugh grant]

Easy.. Mayweather Jr.

Calzaghe didn't fight the same opposition Mayweather fought.

It would have been better if the thread was who is greater between Pacquiao and Mayweather

But it's established Pac s greater than floyd.
It's only natural Floyd will be compared to other unbeaten fighters, as that's the selling and talking point and if Floyd comes out with most respect out of the unbeatens-credit to floyd.
Floyd has pluses and minus and so does calzaghe

[Earl-Hickey]

not really a question, underlined by the fact that Mayweather was finishing his world title career at age 35 at the same age that Calzaghe was just starting his.

Putting the contrast another way, anyone single one of mayweathers's top ten wins eclipses joes entire resume.

You are comparing an ATG with a titlist with a handful of recognised defences, whom are ten a penny.

These guys are poles apart.
The thread does have some value, it shows how records can show polar opposite factual information.

See this is where talking in hyperbole backfires

Is Cotto a top 10 win for Floyd? A shop worn cotto

Prime unbeaten kessler is equivalent to a top 5 win by Floyd, that was a damn good win

Obviously Floyd has a lot more depth, but don't be ****** lol.

[DreamFighter]

See this is where talking in hyperbole backfires

Is Cotto a top 10 win for Floyd? A shop worn cotto

Prime unbeaten kessler is equivalent to a top 5 win by Floyd, that was a damn good win

Obviously Floyd has a lot more depth, but don't be ****** lol.

this is where the hyperolbe backfires, its kessler and thats it.

[KidDinamita]

But it's established Pac s greater than floyd.
It's only natural Floyd will be compared to other unbeaten fighters, as that's the selling and talking point and if Floyd comes out with most respect out of the unbeatens-credit to floyd.
Floyd has pluses and minus and so does calzaghe

Exactly, you are right about that. IMO between a lot of unbeaten fighters, Mayweather deserves the most respect.

[Marchegiano]

I like both fighters and since this is so one sided I wanted to say something to put Joe over, but, I really don't have ****..Floyd's just better in every metric. Joe's a great champ though....y'all go a bit far in your criticisms.

[Zaroku]

JC did travel and beat 2 higher echelon ATGs who weren't green and no CWs.
There's not much between them but I will say floyd, the alternative is Floyd fans hi******* this thread and asking for trouble

I’m hogs king this thread
I have stated Ployd ain’t undefeated his bill chit record. Castillo beat him


F Floyd. He did beat de la ***** , he beat Mosley .. Ortiz was a punk azz hoe.
I was shocked when he took out corralles

I know boxing I fight

I stopped hating Floyd ( he’s a cheater) gets awY with it...

My wife just says who cares that Floyd cheated..

I care.

[VG_Addict]

Floyd's win over Pacquiao is better than ANYONE on Calzaghe's resume.

[Froch_uppercut]

wat, joe avoided someone every other bout, check out his career in detail, every years its "i'm gonna fight this guy" replaced on the date by a loser.

You must be thinking of the times he was trying to get RJJ and BHop in the ring but they wanted none of it from the guy who beat Eubank and Lacey and, well, everyone.