Is Danny Garcias resume now better then Hattons?

[4Corners]

I don't care about size. What has Garcia done at 147? what world class fighter has he beat at 147?

The natural move is for Garcia to go up in weight now after being #1 at 140.

[LeG00N]

The natural move is for Garcia to go up in weight now after being #1 at 140.

who would you like him to beat at 147 to earn a shot at Myweather?

Maybe throw him in there with Berto, that always seems to do the trick

[Larry the boss]

No , Hattons got in the ring with both Manny and Floyd

why would i count losses on someones resume?

[Godsfly]

He was in the top 3 Pound for Pound fighters in the world. And he was younger than Mayweather, Marquez and Martinez are now.

He had injury problems but he came back and blew out Sharmba Mitchell in 3 rounds before he faced Hatton. Mitchell was one of the top fighters at 140 at the time and someone who gave him a little trouble in their first fight.

Hatton was a huge underdog in the fight. I'm not talking Garcia-Matthysse odds either.

Sharmba Mitchell?



you lost me............

[Larry the boss]

Sharmba Mitchell?



you lost me............

Yep he will try to big up Sharmba Mitchell for Kostya but wont give Floyd credit for beating the same Mitchell

[Dirk Diggler UK]

Sharmba Mitchell?



you lost me............

Mitchell was a top fighter at Junior Welterweight at the time. He gave Tszyu some trouble in their first fight. Didn't say he was anything great but Tyszu came back after his injury lay off and destroyed him which was a few months before he faced Hatton.

Yep he will try to big up Sharmba Mitchell for Kostya but wont give Floyd credit for beating the same Mitchell

The hell does Floyd have to do with it? You always try to sound objective and unbiased but then your gay ass fantard side comes out. Who mentioned Floyd? You're fake and transparent as hell man

[Motofan]

Danny has two solid wins. Two.

[4Corners]

Because Matthysse has never beaten a top fighter and Tszuy has. They were on two different levels, people just built Matthysse up to be superman, which he wasn't at all.

Lucas deserved wins over Judah and Alexander, and killed Peterson. He was certainly the man at 140 along with Garcia.

Hatton beat Tszyu, Paulie, Collazo, Maussa, Lazcano.

Garcia's beaten Lucas, Judah, Khan, and Morales.

Morales was past prime but still Top 10 at 140 coming off giving Maidana hell and stopping Cano. Judah is Judah, will always just be a decent win at best, but decent still. Khan was one of the Top 2-3 guys at 140, and Danny was a huge underdog going in. And Lucas was the man at 140 along with Garcia.

Tszyu was the man at 140, but was past prime, still a huge win. Maussa was decent given he'd just beaten Harris, but Maussa is no better than decent win at best. Paulie was a solid win over a Top 10 140 fighter. Collazo was another solid win over a Top 10 147 fighter, but he arguably lost this as well, it was close.

So it's really pretty close.

Danny Garcia is certainly Top 10 P4P now though.

[4Corners]

How are people going to say Judah and Morales weren't solid or decent wins, and than say Hatton had more than 2-3 solid wins???

Judah is Judah, a good solid fighter, nothing more or less. But still a decent win. And Morales was old, but still coming off giving Maidana hell and stopping Cano.

Those wins are certainly equal to Maussa or Paulie, who never really did much of anything from a fight or two.

[4Corners]

who would you like him to beat at 147 to earn a shot at Myweather?

Maybe throw him in there with Berto, that always seems to do the trick

I'd like to see Khan or Garcia fight Guerrero, or even Ortiz.