As of right now who ranks higher,Floyd or Manny

[IronDanHamza]

Oh well, nothing I can do about that. Somebody should mention the amount of past/present/future champs that Floyd has beaten.



Castillo also had his remedy later on in his career, which made those wins (second one mostly) better with time. I think he took Corrales place on the p4p list when he beat him in the rematch.

Sadly Castillo was never a feature on The Ring's P4P list.

I think he should have been though.

[IronDanHamza]

I use to do the same until DLH bought it. Now i dont even look at it. Nothing against DLH. You can see the bias in it.

As far as I'm aware De La Hoya has nothing to do with the P4P rankings or the Magazine in general.

[PACnPBFsuck]

It's always these threads that ruffle the feathers.

[LacedUp]

Sadly Castillo was never a feature on The Ring's P4P list.

I think he should have been though.

i thought he was there in 2000 or something after beating johnston who was ranked at the bottom. Could be wrong though.

Did he not make it in 2005 after Corrales II ?

[usamvp boxing]

Floyd ranks higher. Undefeated, beat JMM every round easily, Pac lost a debatable match to Bradley. History books will lean towards floyd being greater.

[IronDanHamza]

i thought he was there in 2000 or something after beating johnston who was ranked at the bottom. Could be wrong though.

Did he not make it in 2005 after Corrales II ?

I didn't think he had but I just checked and it seems you're right he did get on there in the mid 00's.

Baffling to me considering he should have been on there much earlier.

[LacedUp]

I didn't think he had but I just checked and it seems you're right he did get on there in the mid 00's.

Baffling to me considering he should have been on there much earlier.

He should have been there after Johnston, I honestly thought he was. Regardless, I would probably say either him or Corrales is Mayweather's best win. But when you look at Floyd's record it's just evident that it just has that little more depth than Pacquiaos.

[IronDanHamza]

He should have been there after Johnston, I honestly thought he was. Regardless, I would probably say either him or Corrales is Mayweather's best win. But when you look at Floyd's record it's just evident that it just has that little more depth than Pacquiaos.

Castillo's his best win, for me.

Greatest Lightweight of his era, greatest Lightweight of the last 20 years, much smaller fighter.

Castillo's so underrated IMO I would vote for him for the HOF but I doubt he will make it.

[B Phontain]

Castillo's his best win, for me.

Greatest Lightweight of his era, greatest Lightweight of the last 20 years, much smaller fighter.

Castillo's so underrated IMO I would vote for him for the HOF but I doubt he will make it.

what do u mean by the bold?

[Jack Napier]

f u c k a southpaw

aesthetically make for horrible fights, ruins the artistery of the sport.

you must not like Whitaker then
and anyway, what's that got to do with resumes?