As of right now who ranks higher,Floyd or Manny

[James_Toney]

for argument sake.... let's say pacquiao's fought the better fighters and had the harder fights....

but as far as boxing, pure boxing goes.....

there's no comparison.....

pacquiao's great, but you don't take a young kid to the gym and try and recreate pacquiao's style....

you look at fighters like, floyd mayweather, bernard hopkins, mike mccallum, james toney, alexis arguello....

pacquiao being a southpaw automatically diminishes his legacy.

[$tate of Mind]

how much higher can you go after 8 division titles?



Posted from Boxingscene.com App for Android

When's the last time Manny won a fight?

[HeroBando]

Well you can actually get 8 to start with

True, but by the same standard the closest runner up is at 5. And we know Floyd is too small for 5 even

[Jack Napier]

for argument sake.... let's say pacquiao's fought the better fighters and had the harder fights....

but as far as boxing, pure boxing goes.....

there's no comparison.....

pacquiao's great, but you don't take a young kid to the gym and try and recreate pacquiao's style....

you look at fighters like, floyd mayweather, bernard hopkins, mike mccallum, james toney, alexis arguello....

pacquiao being a southpaw automatically diminishes his legacy.

uh, what?

[PAC-BOY]

When's the last time Manny won a fight?

whens the last time Floyd was in a exciting fight?

[hhs661]

Floyd as of right now and he's looking to gain a bigger lead if he defeats Canelo imo. Floyd's longevity, dominance and opponents has him ahead if I were to vote.

Both resumes could be dissected if people would do it fairly, but one being ahead of the other isn't a slap in the face to Manny or Floyd. These guys are two of the best of the past 15+ years

[Fetta]

whens the last time Floyd was in a exciting fight?

I thought the Cotto fight was pretty exciting. Then again i love boxing and watch it all for the brawlers and boxers.

[PAC-BOY]

for argument sake.... let's say pacquiao's fought the better fighters and had the harder fights....

but as far as boxing, pure boxing goes.....

there's no comparison.....

pacquiao's great, but you don't take a young kid to the gym and try and recreate pacquiao's style....

you look at fighters like, floyd mayweather, bernard hopkins, mike mccallum, james toney, alexis arguello....

pacquiao being a southpaw automatically diminishes his legacy.

[Larry the boss]

whens the last time Floyd was in a exciting fight?

LMFAO,stop PacBoy this is embarrassing,what in the hell does that heve to do with anything?

[James_Toney]

uh, what?

f u c k a southpaw

aesthetically make for horrible fights, ruins the artistery of the sport.