Comments Thread For: BoxingScene Update: Pound for Pound List and Review

[Carpe Diem]

WAIT, so Pacquiao is still top 10, but Nonito is off, I understand Nonito being off, but no one in the boxing community can justify Pac on any top 10 PFP list.

I'm more surprised that he wasn't on the Top 5 list. I expect Boxingscene to put him on the top 3 list after he KO/TKO Rios.

[bravestone]

Look how far Martinez dropped for struggling with Murray. Yet Manny is KTFO and stays top 10. Sheesh.

[sigrab jr]

I've been bashing Cliff Rold's P4P lists for over 5 years now. Though I don't see how Carl Froch is a top 5 P4P fighter, there is a vast improvement in Rold's P4P list compared to recent years. I can't really say anything bad about this list. I think Wlad should be over Pacquiao. Rold's weak point has always been Pacquiao, you always put him where he doesn't belong or in front of fighters who are doing better than him. I know you will put him even higher after he pummels Rios, who also is coming off a loss.

I can live with Donaire at #8 for getting outboxed by Rigondeaux. But Pacquiao got knocked out cold, dude, you got it all wrong, Donaire should be #8, not taken off entirely. Pacquiao should not be there. He has lost officially and unofficially, 2 of his last 3 fights. That is no Top 10 P4P fighter.

Other than that, this is a really good, fresh list, Cliff. It has some new names there, rather than keeping names just because they are popular.

[bravestone]

I'm more surprised that he wasn't on the Top 5 list. I expect Boxingscene to put him on the top 3 list after he KO/TKO Rios.

No kidding. This site is awesome but it seems very Pro-Pacquiao.

[HeroBando]

I've been bashing Cliff Rold's P4P lists for over 5 years now. Though I don't see how Carl Froch is a top 5 P4P fighter, there is a vast improvement in Rold's P4P list compared to recent years. I can't really say anything bad about this list. I think Wlad should be over Pacquiao. Rold's weak point has always been Pacquiao, you always put him where he doesn't belong or in front of fighters who are doing better than him. I know you will put him even higher after he pummels Rios, who also is coming off a loss.

I can live with Donaire at #8 for getting outboxed by Rigondeaux. But Pacquiao got knocked out cold, dude, you got it all wrong, Donaire should be #8, not taken off entirely. Pacquiao should not be there. He has lost officially and unofficially, 2 of his last 3 fights. That is no Top 10 P4P fighter.

Other than that, this is a really good, fresh list, Cliff. It has some new names there, rather than keeping names just because they are popular.

Espn, Ring, tbrb.org... May I suggest Frank Duckett's p4p rankings for something more up your alley?

[Sugar Adam Ali]

Manny stays in my top ten because i thought he dominated bradley and was dominating jmm..

Serg is not because he got beat down by Murray and should have lost, and serg looks super old and broken down

Doniare not on my list becasue he got completely dismantled in a big fight...
Manny never got dominated like those 2 did, he just walked into a huge counter right in a fight he was winning...
Just my opinion on why he on and those two off

[crold1]

I've been bashing Cliff Rold's P4P lists for over 5 years now. Though I don't see how Carl Froch is a top 5 P4P fighter, there is a vast improvement in Rold's P4P list compared to recent years. I can't really say anything bad about this list. I think Wlad should be over Pacquiao. Rold's weak point has always been Pacquiao, you always put him where he doesn't belong or in front of fighters who are doing better than him. I know you will put him even higher after he pummels Rios, who also is coming off a loss.

I can live with Donaire at #8 for getting outboxed by Rigondeaux. But Pacquiao got knocked out cold, dude, you got it all wrong, Donaire should be #8, not taken off entirely. Pacquiao should not be there. He has lost officially and unofficially, 2 of his last 3 fights. That is no Top 10 P4P fighter.

Other than that, this is a really good, fresh list, Cliff. It has some new names there, rather than keeping names just because they are popular.

Can't please all the people all the time, but can get anyone once. LOL thanks to the kind words.

[crold1]

Manny stays in my top ten because i thought he dominated bradley and was dominating jmm..

Serg is not because he got beat down by Murray and should have lost, and serg looks super old and broken down

Doniare not on my list becasue he got completely dismantled in a big fight...
Manny never got dominated like those 2 did, he just walked into a huge counter right in a fight he was winning...
Just my opinion on why he on and those two off

He could easily still be there. Almost bumped Wlad but feel Wlad merits at least a spot as the literal best fighter on earth IMO. It's a crowded field.

[bravestone]

Mayweather
Marquez
Ward
Martinez
Rigondeaux
Wladmir
Mares
Froch
Bradley
Donaire

How it should be.

[p4p-champ]

IMO, Floyd is #1 p4p overall, then Ward. But, that's not surprising from this place.


lol @ Manny still on the list.