Comments Thread For: BoxingScene Update: Pound for Pound List and Review

[sigrab jr]

Espn, Ring, tbrb.org... May I suggest Frank Duckett's p4p rankings for something more up your alley?

The only thing I really criticized in his list was Pacquiao still being there.

Froch is not top 5 but he is top 10 so that's not that big of a deal. This P4P list is pretty accurate in who the current best fighters are, outside of just one guy.

[T18Z]

Mayweather
Marquez
Ward
Martinez
Rigondeaux
Wladmir
Mares
Froch
Bradley
Donaire

How it should be.

The guy who got beat up by Pacquaio and Ruslan Provodnikov, an ESPN fight night guy who isn't even close to being on the p4p list?

He practically robbed one and if the ref in the 2nd fight wasn't a ****** he'd of lost the 2nd too. He shouldn't be on the list.

Pacquaio is on close to every official P4P list for a reason, I explained why earlier, seems people are too blind to realize themselves. 1 loss to a fellow P4P fighter doesn't get you thrown off the list unless you were already at 7/8/9/10th spot.

[bravestone]

The guy who got beat up by Pacquaio and Ruslan Provodnikov, an ESPN fight night guy who isn't even close to being on the p4p list?

He practically robbed one and if the ref in the 2nd fight wasn't a ****** he'd of lost the 2nd too. He shouldn't be on the list.

Pacquaio is on close to every official P4P list for a reason, I explained why earlier, seems people are too blind to realize themselves. 1 loss to a fellow P4P fighter doesn't get you thrown off the list unless you were already at 7/8/9/10th spot.

Bradley beat Provodnikov. Pacquiao lost twice to an old lightweight.

[T18Z]

Bradley beat Provodnikov.

Bet you also think he beat Pacquaio

The ref missed 2 knockdowns, and should've stopped the fight when Bradley fell flat on his face after standing up from a knockdown.

Also, age doesn't matter to every fighter as much, as shown by Marquez, Mayweather, Pacquaio, Bernard Hopkins etc, just log off.

[bravestone]

Bet you also think he beat Pacquaio

The ref missed 2 knockdowns, and should've stopped the fight when Bradley fell flat on his face after standing up from a knockdown.

Also, age doesn't matter to every fighter as much, as shown by Marquez, Mayweather, Pacquaio, Bernard Hopkins etc, just log off.

Hopkins isn't P4P numpty.

I had Pac vs Bradley for Pac by the way so **** right off

[HeroBando]

The only thing I really criticized in his list was Pacquiao still being there.

Froch is not top 5 but he is top 10 so that's not that big of a deal. This P4P list is pretty accurate in who the current best fighters are, outside of just one guy.

Fair enough, just saying, you can levy same criticism on any respectable p4p list, cause Pac is in all of them, often higher than here.

[thuggery]

It's a decent list, though I don't consider an inactive headbutting clincher as #1. Wlad is far too low.

[T18Z]

Hopkins isn't P4P numpty.

I had Pac vs Bradley for Pac by the way so **** right off

Good for you, and the point was that age doesn't automatically make a fighter worth any less. Floyd, Manny and Marquez are all in the aging numbers, yet they're all still p4p material, so your theory sucks balls.

[bravestone]

Good for you, and the point was that age doesn't automatically make a fighter worth any less. Floyd, Manny and Marquez are all in the aging numbers, yet they're all still p4p material, so your theory sucks balls.

Manny going 1-2 in his last 3 doesn't make him P4P material.

[Reloaded]

The only thing I really criticized in his list was Pacquiao still being there.

Froch is not top 5 but he is top 10 so that's not that big of a deal. This P4P list is pretty accurate in who the current best fighters are, outside of just one guy.

And Bradley is not in it , seems like a biased list but I suppose they all are .