Where does Manny rank all time?

[ROSS CALIFORNIA]

Forget achievements, I bet there are not 10 welterweights in history that could have beat the 2009 Manny Pacquiao.

[dan_cov]

definitely inside top 10..the GOAT southpaw..

Pernell Whitaker, Marvin Hagler, Tiger Flowers...

[Prince_Pugilist]

40-50, too low, top 10, too high. I'd have him top 25, somewhere around 20....fighters ranked clearly above him are obviously those in my top 10 and then guys like Leonard, Hearns, Holmes etc. Not many names throughout history have accomplished what he has, few have gained his popularity and fewer have been as ferocious. One of the best offensive fighters of all time!

[IronDanHamza]

What number exactly? Throw something solid out there. Give us a definitive number.

Don't think he has an exact number.

Might be why he said "Top 50".

Perhaps he could clarify.

[lparm]

Don't think he has an exact number.

Might be why he said "Top 50".

Perhaps he could clarify.

Ok so let's low ball and say he meant number 40 because he did say 40-50.

So name 39 other fighters in history that have better accomplishments than Manny.

[puga]

this coming from the late bert sugar himself ..in 2009

[puga]

Pernell Whitaker, Marvin Hagler, Tiger Flowers...

[The Hoff]

<< Good **** you're smoking!

Everyday! Can't get enough of MaryJane, pal.

smoke crack everyday

I am not a Mayweather, buddy... or a Hatton.

Anywho, let's get back to one of thee greatest fighters of our time!

Long live Manny "PacMonster" Pacquiao!

[Prince_Pugilist]

I couldn't agree more. Pacquiao is a greater southpaw than Whitaker and Flowers...but Hagler? No. Pacquiao's achievements are phenomenol, head to head, I think he'd beat Whitaker at any weight. I know, I know, Pacs had problems with Marquez, but Whitaker liked to frustrate opponents and had almost 0 punch power, Marquez not only hits harder bt he is a far more aggressive counter puncher who NEVER fools around. Pacs work rate is enough to beat Sweat Pea, let alone power, speed, stamina, chin etc.

[-MAKAVELLI-]

that's a tough one..so many great fighters from the past


imma go with #1