Better resume Jmm or Cotto

[-jose-]

They both have great resumes...they both are warriors!
Miguel Cotto is my choice at the end

[LeG00N]

Jmm was lineal in 2 divisions true so i give him that over Cotto.but Cotto has beaten the better fighters imo........

Old Barrera is greater than everyone on Cotto's resume....


wait, but you don't think highly of Barrera... since you've made threads to discredit his entire career

[Larry the boss]

They both have great resumes...they both are warriors!
Miguel Cotto is my choice at the end

yes both are damn sho warriors

[El_Forklift]

JMM he has a draw with Pac

Cotto didnt come close to it

And JMM always beats strong contenders man

Cotto to but JMM kos them

but both havent got many breaks always tough fights

[LoadedWraps]

Who has the better resume and who should get inducted in the hall of fame first?

Jmm-
1-Barerra
2-Casamyor
3-Diaz
4-Juarez
5-Katsidas

Cotto

1-Mosley
2-Margo
3-Quintana
4-Judah
5-Mallinaggi

JMM. don't forget to put Manny in JMM's win list too by the way.

[Larry the boss]

Old Barrera is greater than everyone on Cotto's resume....


wait, but you don't think highly of Barrera... since you've made threads to discredit his entire career

old Barrera is not better than everyone on Cottos resume what the hell did he accomplish other than losing after the JMM fight?

[MalikKnucklez]

marquez cant beat prime barrera...

what makes u think that?

[Larry the boss]

JMM. don't forget to put Manny in JMM's win list too by the way.

but he never beat Manny officially man.im only counting official wins

[LeG00N]

Marquez beating Salido > Cotto getting stopped then beating a shot Margarito


Salido should've been added Margarito shouldn't be on that list. It's a mediocre win just like Cotto's entire 154lbs run

[BennyST]

I love all the names that people have brought up for Cotto, but not mentioned any of the others for Marquez.

Either way, Manuel Medina is greater than Katsidis and Juarez by a mile and better than just about anyone on Cotto's resume not named Mosley. He's a 6 time champ and FW great. What about Smoke Gainer?
Orlando Salido?
Julio Gervacio?
Robbie Peden?
Alfred Kotey?
Agapito Sanchez?

All of these guys were/are top champs.

Even Polo, who was twice majorly robbed of title wins, is better than Katsidis (as much as I love him).

Anyway, it's Marquez for me.
Casamayor
Diaz
Barrera
Pacquiao
Gainer
Medina
Salido
Sanchez
Peden
Kotey
etc
etc

There are champions in that list (and more champs that weren't listed) that go from 1990 to current champs right now and Marquez has beaten all of them. Yes, all of them. That's a 22 year span of champions beaten.

They also range from champions at Bantamweight all the way to Jr middleweight champions. Well, I'm not sure I can say JMW with any seriousness, but...

That's champions across 22 years and through bantamweight, superbantamweight, featherweight, superfeatherweight, lightweight, Jr welterweight, welterweight and a fake JMW.