Better resume Jmm or Cotto

[Larry the boss]

Who has the better resume and who should get inducted in the hall of fame first?

Jmm-
1-Barerra
2-Casamyor
3-Diaz
4-Juarez
5-Katsidas

Cotto

1-Mosley
2-Margo
3-Quintana
4-Judah
5-Mallinaggi

[bojangles1987]

Definitely Marquez.

[savorduhflavor]

Marquez, no doubt.

[Roy Jones Jnr]

Marquez, and it's not even close.

Also you forgot Pacquiao's name from his list of wins.

[RichCCFC]

Definitely Marquez and you have to give him credit for at least a share of the Pacquiao fights.

[Twako]

so we have to give credit to castillo for his share of his floyd fights too?

[chibomber]

Marquez for sure. Putting Katsidis on that list doesn't make him look good. Katsidis is exciting but no where near great.

[RajahBell]

A journeyman fighter as JMM's 4th best win?? Rocky Juarez was never a World Champ. Cotto has the better Resume' since Malignaggi at least won a world title.

[ELHURACAN58]

Cotto.

Would have picked Marquez if Casamayor hadnt been brutally beaten against Santa Cruz before their fight.

Prime Barrera>Prime Mosley
Washed up Casamayor<One eyed Margarito
Diaz>Quintana
Juarez<Judah
Katsidis<Malignaggi

So its Miguel for me.

[dibzvincent143]

pretty close, fan of both..