Is Pacquiao the great P4P King of the modern era?

[Alonzo Harris]

Hey I voted for Pernell.........And it looks like I'm the only one.

Pernell is Incredibly Underappreiced on this forum.

For me it goes Roy, Pernell and then Floyd.

[kadyo's]

Anybody knows who stays the longest within top 10 so far?

[The Big Dunn]

Pernell is Incredibly Underappreiced on this forum.

For me it goes Roy, Pernell and then Floyd.

Pernell is overlooked. I mean the difference between floyd and pernell is really only floyds mouth!

[junior gong]

Pernell is overlooked. I mean the difference between floyd and pernell is really only floyds mouth!

And Pernell's superior skill of course.

[The Big Dunn]

And Pernell's superior skill of course.

I think I'd give a slight edge to floyd but if you go sweet pea I'd have no problem. Unless of course the posters opinion is based more on how they feel about floyd rather than an honest asessement of each fighters skill set.

[Elotero]

Roy Jones is the best fighter of those listed on the poll
it would be between him and Whitaker

It was a toss up for me too.

Went with Sweat Pea though. Roy is also an excellent choice.

[junior gong]

I think I'd give a slight edge to floyd but if you go sweet pea I'd have no problem. Unless of course the posters opinion is based more on how they feel about floyd rather than an honest asessement of each fighters skill set.

Pernell was just a better fighter imo. I'm no expert on Feeling about Floyd as I dont live on planet bumsniff, but perhaps you could give us all an insight!

[Brother Jay]

Pernell is Incredibly Underappreiced on this forum.

For me it goes Roy, Pernell and then Floyd.

For me it goes Roy, Floyd and then Pernell.

[Phenom]

without a doubt the most overrated great in modern era in that time frame 2008-present Pacquiao fought #1 ranked in the division only once and we all know Hatton wasn't the same anymore.

fought at 3 catchweight and another 2 of his opponent had to come down a division

[The Big Dunn]

Pernell was just a better fighter imo. I'm no expert on Feeling about Floyd as I dont live on planet bumsniff, but perhaps you could give us all an insight!

Your personal opinion about floyd as a person seems to drive your answers in these types of threads. But you are entitled to your opinion. As I said, picking pernell is fine with me.

Does that make you a sweet pea bumsniffer?